4 Reasons to Avoid Diet Soda

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
by Fawne Hansen

Sugar has been demonstrated by many studies to be one of the main causes of obesity. Because sugar is full of calories and has no nutritional value, a high-sugar diet is unlikely to contain enough nutrients necessary to maintain good health, and will likely also lead to weight gain. This not only puts us at risk of serious illnesses such as diabetes and cardiovascular disease, but also has adverse effects on our endurance, speed of recovery after exercise, and more.

Over the past 10-15 years, this has led many consumers to switch to ‘diet’ forms of their favorite drinks and foods. These contain less sugar and fewer calories, and are marketed as ‘healthier’ and guilt-free compared to their sugary counterparts. However, the truth is that the artificial sweeteners contained in them can have just as negative an effect on your health as regular sugar can. In fact, sometimes you’d be better to stick with the sugary soda rather than trying the ‘diet’ version.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) has confirmed in a report that Americans today consume a lot more sugar than they used to, and a lot more sugar than most of the rest of the world. Compared to just three decades ago, the world daily average consumption of sugar has increased by 46%. As it stands, the average American consumes around 156 pounds of sugar every year. Most of that sugar comes from the food and the liquids that they consume. The biggest source of that sugar is sweet drinks. These sugary concoctions account for about 10% of the total sugar consumption.

One method that consumers often use to decrease their sugar intake is to switch to diet sodas, drinks that are supposed to be healthier due to their low or zero sugar content. Just this simple substitution can remove anywhere from 200 to 1000 calories from the daily diet of an individual. However, the effects are not as positive as most would think. This is because the artificial sweeteners used in these diet sodas still trigger the body into behaving as if it just absorbed regular sugar. So even if there is no actual sugar entering your bloodstream, your blood sugar levels will increase just the same.

1. Diet Soda and Weight Loss
The main reason why people switch from regular soda to diet soda is weight loss. After all, diet sodas have a lot fewer calories than regular sodas, so it stands to reason that it would help with weight loss. However, studies have shown that drinking diet soda does nothing to trigger or benefit weight loss in any way. In fact, drinking diet soda can be just as unhealthy (or even more so) as drinking regular soda due to the presence of artificial sweeteners.

One study performed on animals and published by the National Center for Biotechnology Information (1) showed that diet soda can be linked with weight gain by increasing the appetite and slowing down the metabolism of the test animals. This has also been confirmed by another study performed on humans where the people who consumed diet foods put on weight due to a tendency to overeat. This behavior is triggered not only by physical reactions occurring in the body, but also by psychological ones – people think they are saving on calories by consuming diet foods instead of normal ones and therefore they think that eating more is ok because it is balanced out.

2. Diet Soda and Diabetes
Another reason why diet soda is preferred by many people is the perceived notion that cutting back on sugar will decrease the chances of developing type 2 diabetes. While there is a link between consumption of sweet beverages and diabetes, the idea that consuming lots of sugar alone leads to diabetes is a myth, as stated by the American Diabetes Association.(2) The truth is that there are many factors that can be a cause for diabetes, including genetics, age, ethnicity and being overweight. However, since being overweight is actually what puts people at risk for diabetes, and since diet soda does not help with weight loss, there is no reason to believe that the latter can have a beneficial effect in preventing diabetes.

One notable study which was published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition showed exactly this.(3) This was a long 14-year study covering the effects of all diet foods and their relation to diabetes which targeted over 66,000 women. The study showed that consumption of both sugar-sweetened beverages and artificially sweetened beverages increased the risk of developing type 2 diabetes.

3. Diet Soda and Tooth Decay
People who are aware that sodas will have an adverse effect on oral health should also know that the same can be said about diet sodas. This is because the main difference between them is sugar content and it is not the sugar which causes tooth decay, it is the citric acid. Carbonated beverages are quite acidic with an average pH of 3.2. Years of drinking soda regularly, regardless of whether it is diet or not, will wear away the enamel which covers the teeth and acts as a protective layer. Because of this, teeth will not only suffer discoloration, but will also be at a higher risk of developing cracks and cavities. Again, due to a psychological factor, people who regularly drink diet soda are actually more affected because they tend to drink more since they think that it is safe and healthy compared to regular soda.

4. Artificial Sweeteners in Diet Soda
Most of the problems generated by diet soda are due to the presence of artificial sweeteners which sometimes can be just as bad, if not worse, than regular sugar. While sugar has been studied for a long time and its effects on the body are well-documented, sweeteners come in many forms and new ones are always being developed, so it is hard to say that they will all have the same effect on the human body and what that effect might be. However, existing research does point to some disturbing effects.

There are links between aspartame (the sweetener used in most diet sodas) and seizures, migraines and other neurological problems, as well as cancer.(4) One long 11-year study conducted by Harvard Medical School was not enough to provide conclusive evidence, but it did show a link between diet soda and kidney problems after studying over 3,000 women.(5) Since there is no such connection with regular soda, it is suspected that the sweeteners involved were the culprits.

Further Reading
(1) Swithers et al, 2008, “A role for sweet taste: calorie predictive relations in energy regulation by rats”, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18298259.
(2) American Diabetes Association, “Diabetes myths”, http://www.diabetes.org/diabetes-basics/myths/.
(3) Fagherazzi et al, 2013, “Consumption of artificially and sugar-sweetened beverages and incident type 2 diabetes in the Etude Epidémiologique auprès des femmes de la Mutuelle Générale de l’Education Nationale”, http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/early/2013/01/30/ajcn.112.050997.
(4) The Candida Diet, “If You’re On A Candida Diet, Avoid Aspartame”, http://www.thecandidadiet.com/aspartame-and-candida/.
(5) WebMD, “Diet sodas may be hard on the kidneys”, http://www.webmd.com/diet/news/20091102/diet-sodas-hard-on-the-kidneys.

Printable Version

We Are Scouting Top Writers

Are you passionate about fitness and have something to say? Reach a huge online community and get the discussion going - start writing for Tabata Times today!

Share this post
@TabataTimes on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook 
Advertise Here

Most Popular of All Time

zmosbarger published the post The Tug-o-War Between Playing to Your Strengths and Staying Constantly Varied on Tabata Times
We have been on the road for eighteen days now, a time span that has allowed us to visit fourteen...
szurley published the post Skipping Leg Day on
OK so you are probably rolling your eyes thinking about the last time someone at a CrossFit gym...
CrossFit Fairfax shared a link on Facebook

Two weeks before our Nutrition Challenge officially starts!

CrossFit Reston shared a link on Facebook

Two weeks before our Nutrition Challenge officially starts!

CrossFit Falls Church shared an image on Facebook

Last call before Fall Whole 30 kicks off September 17th! Join Amy and Bonny at CFA September 11th, 7:00 pm if you have any questions about this CFA/CFFC challenge! Folks who want to drop off their $25 buy-in are free to come by and do that as well! Note: If you have already attended info sessions for Whole 30 before then this meeting is completely optional. Just email Amy and Bonny that you would like to join! harris.amy22@gmail.com and bonnyc@gmail.com

CrossFit Reston posted on Facebook

Happy birthday to Sarah Pomeroy!! Birthday burpees > spinning!!!

CrossFit Chesapeake shared an image on Facebook

We are a week into our "Everything in Moderation" Nutrition Challenge. The high-fat, low-carb approach is taking some people out of their comfort zones. Not so for Tara, she's posting some gourmet-lookin' pictures on our challenge group page. Whether you're doing the challenge or not, have you tried any new recipes this week? Share them with us! That's what the community is for :) (Thanks to Tara for the photo!)

tarynhaggerstone published the post CrossFit: What Makes a Good Competition? on
Over the past couple years, the number of people who do CrossFit has gone through the roof, and...
Fentress CrossFit posted on Facebook

Wednesday's WOD: 21-15-9 Over the bar Burpees Power Cleans 135/95# Then 50 Sit-Ups 50 Ball Slams

paleobutter published the post Paleo Paella on Nutrition WOD
This is a Paleo version of the Valencia style of paella. Adaptions include smoked/ grilled chicken...
Patriot CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Once you learn how to Pose, fall, and pull you must learn one other crucial piece of running technique: cadence. […]

CrossFit Shadyside shared a link on Facebook


CrossFit Advance posted on Facebook

For those of you with smartphones there is a free app you can download to automatically calculate your weights for this new strength cycle. Search "Wendler Calculator" or "5/3/1 Calculator" all you have to do is enter you 1 Rep Max and make sure the "use 90%" is activated, and it will tell you what whats to use.

Compound CrossFit posted an article
Ballston CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

J. Humenay published the post Answering The Question - "Why Do You Lift?" on
Recently, I've been asked the question, "Why do you do Olympic lifts? There are so many other ways...
CrossFit Chesapeake posted an article
CrossFit Rosslyn posted an article
CrossFit Falls Church shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit Rosslyn shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit Rosslyn shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit Rosslyn shared an image on Facebook

Patriot CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

When Serious Becomes TOO Serious Many of us take our fitness, and our training, pretty seriously. Serious is good — it allows you to dedicate yourself to getting better at...

CrossFit Pittsburgh posted an article
CrossFit Arlington shared a link on Facebook

Wed 10 Aug 2014 http://wp.me/p2SUDs-1cT

CrossFit Arlington posted an article
Trident CrossFit posted an article
Patriot CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit Integrated Fitness shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Reston shared a link on Facebook

Skill - Strict HSPU 4 rounds for time: • 10 Strict HSPU • 15 Power Snatch 95#/65# Core - 2 x 15 Good Mornings 45/33#

CrossFit Old Town shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Pittsburgh posted on Facebook

Available right now: 1 pair of Men's Cordura WOD Shorts Size 33" Retail $60.00 yours for $40.00.

astewart30 published the post Size Doesn't Matter on
From the time I was 10 years old I have been aware of my size. I have always known how much I weigh...
CrossFit KSX posted on Facebook

Tuesday's Workout Strength: 10 min EMOM 3 Deadlift @ 70% of 3RM Conditioning: 12min EMOM 3 Power cleans 155/115 5 strict pull-ups Rest 2 min: 3 rounds of: 1 min elbow plank 45 sec max supermans 30 sec Russian twist with weight 20/15 * 30 sec rest between rounds*

CrossFit Iron City posted on Facebook

This week's challenge is: 3 min AMRAP of 20 DU's Jason L. already has 2 wins down, who is going to take the top spot this week?

CrossFit Arlington shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit Center City shared a link on Facebook

#DIDYOUKNOW that CFCC offers Custom Fit Meals? These fresh, healthy meals are a great option for weeks when you're especially busy. They offer a huge menu that rotates week to week, and there's no commitment required. Use code CENTERCITY to take 10% off your first order. If you're thinking about participating in the #cfccrecharge or are struggling to find healthy options on-the-go, give CFM a try! #nutrition #paleo #paleoish http://crossfitcc.com/a-new-option-for-healthy-convenient-eats-at-cfcc/

CrossFit Center City shared an image on Facebook

Don't forget we are holding a 2 hour introductory Strongman clinic on Sunday September 28th. Link to sign up is in the comments. Email Record at record@crossfitcc.com if you have any questions about it and remember it is open to both CFCC member and non-members!

CrossFit Prime posted an article
CrossFit Prime posted an article
CrossFit Athletics posted on Facebook

SFH Fish Oil and *new* pure protein (without Creatine) is in stock!! Get it while it's hot.

Kristy Parrish published the post How Julie Foucher Became Julie Foucher on
Editor's Note: "How Julie Foucher Became Julie Foucher" was originally posted to the Beyond the...
WhatWouldJohnMackEat published the post Portuguese Style Littleneck Clams on
Littleneck clams are hands down my favorite seafood. I eat them raw, steamed or cooked Portuguese...
CrossFit Prime posted an article
CrossFit Focus shared an image on Facebook

Jeremiah swinging the kettlebell with authority.

CrossFit Focus shared a link on Facebook

You don't get what you want - you get what you work for.

Breaking Point Fitness CrossFit Ridge Ave posted on Facebook

Tuesday 9/9/14 15 mins to work to heavy Snatch deadlift + snatch pull + snatch For time: 10 power cleans 185/125 20 burpee over bar 30 toe 2 bar 200ft farmers carry 55/35 30 toe 2 bar 20 burpee over bar 10 power cleans

CrossFit Center City shared a link on Facebook

Learn all about the newest cycle leading up to the CrossFit Total on Halloween! Deadlift and Strict Press Tuesday tomorrow! http://crossfitcc.com/workout-of-the-day-tuesday-9-9-14/

CrossFit RDU shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Invoke shared an image on Facebook

Body Comp Challenge is in full swing. Be sure to make these next 12 weeks worth it! #cfinvoke #cfiathlete #cfibootycamp #crossfit #bodycomp #fat #relentlesslife #weighin #eatright #nutrition #goals #progress

CrossFit King of Prussia posted an article
CrossFit RDU posted an article
CrossFit Gastonia shared a link on Facebook

Tuesday's WOD http://www.crossfitgastonia.com/w-o-d

CrossFit Delaware Valley shared an image on Facebook

6pm cleanin' and dubbin'!

CrossFit Delaware Valley shared an image on Facebook

N'Sync! (See what I did there? Lol)

Breaking Point Fitness CrossFit Ridge Ave shared a link on Facebook

There is still space left to register for the Carl Paoli seminar at CrossFit Ridge Ave on September 20th from 9am-5pm. The seminar is $295 with discounts offered for CF Level 1 Certified Trainers, Educators, Military/Fire/Police/Rescue and USA Gymnastics members! https://freestyleconnection.pushpress.com/open/event/freestyle-connection-seminar---philadelphia-pa

CrossFit 77 shared an image on Facebook

What an awesome start to our Let's Move class on Saturday September 6! Remember this class is free every Saturday from 10:30-11:30 bring your kids and their friends! We can't wait to see the turn out for this Saturday!

CrossFit Focus shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit 77 posted on Facebook

George just PR'd his back squat by 50lbs! 365# like a champ!

CrossFit Wake Forest posted on Facebook

9/9/2014 WOD: Push Press 3-3-3-3-3 Use the heaviest weight you can for each set. Rest as needed between sets. Then: 4 rounds for time of: Run, 200 m 10 Kettlebell Swings

@TabataTimes on Twitter

Watch the latest episode of GPTV