Ask The Doc: Achieving Intensity in Training… Without Getting Rhabdo

Love to Eat? Introducing

Are you passionate about food, nutrition and recipes? Unleash your inner foodie and check out our brand-new site - share your favorite recipes at Nutrition-WOD today!

Print
by KYLE SELA|PT, DPT, SCS, OCS, CSCS, NICHOLE BLEUMLE|PT, DPT, MS, OCS, CSCS, & JARED WILLIAMSON|PT, DPT, SCS, OCS, CSCS

Ask The Doc: Achieving Intensity in Training... Without Getting Rhabdo
A recent article by a well-respected physical therapist has made some traction on social media with regard to CrossFit, rhabdomyolysis (“rhabdo”) and the potential dangers of poor programming in a competitive culture. Essentially, the article highlights the point that if you have a motivated and capable person perform a poorly programmed workout, the risk for rhabdo is increased. 

It is unfortunate when good intentions lead to serious injury. Any workout program, exercise routine, or athletic event comes with risks; those risks can be mitigated but never completely eliminated. We as athletes accept these remaining risks because they are preferable to a sedentary lifestyle and the insidious onset of preventable chronic disease. That being said, you can indeed have too much of a good thing — more is not always better, even when it comes to exercise. This article will explain how to prevent a potentially life-threatening medical condition with sound CrossFit-centric programming techniques.

Risk Perspective

We would like to address the debate with a solution rather than blanket criticism. Rhabdo and so many other training injuries really are preventable…even in CrossFit.
Let me tell you about a “sport” that’s very popular right now. People drop dead during competitions every year… and not just untrained first-timers who haven’t had a drink of water in the last 48 hours. We’re talking veterans of the sport and world-class athletes. Injury rates during training have been reported by upwards of 90% of its participants [Br J Sports Med 1996; 30: 324–6 ]. Its participants have an almost cultish dedication to the sport, getting tattoos and posting cryptic bumper stickers, wearing funny-looking shoes and training their bodies so hard that you can almost pick them out in a crowd just by looking at them.

The “sport” I’m talking about is marathon running. Surprising? Maybe you thought I was going to say CrossFit. When was the last time you read an article bemoaning the dangerous cultish-ness of running? Where are the outrage and spook articles by physical therapists and the greater medical community?

They’ve been done… thirty years ago, that is. When running a 5k was still a feather in your cap, there were plenty of skeptical articles by reputable clinicians. CrossFit and other “extreme conditioning programs” — as they are sometimes called — are just the jogging (pronounced, “yogging”…I think it’s Swedish, but you basically just run) of our day.

At Back to the Box, we feel that CrossFit has been a beneficial tool that has introduced millions of people to training for performance instead of merely for aesthetics. While it has some issues (just like any program), we embrace the opportunity to be part of this growing community and hope to help educate the athletes, coaches and programmers who really just want to improve health and fitness levels.

We would like to address the debate with a solution rather than blanket criticism. Rhabdo and so many other training injuries really are preventable… even in CrossFit. Instead of merely highlighting a potential problem, we’d like to suggest some areas of caution and emphasis in your programming.

Prevention: Training Smart, Programming Right

Prevention: Training Smart, Programming Right

Time domains, time caps and short workouts are vitally important to effective CrossFit programming, and in my experience, this is where many CrossFit affiliates make mistakes.
Exercise-induced rhabdomyolysis is caused by excessive volume relative to an athlete’s current training status. I repeat, rhabdo from exercise is brought on by too much volume (think: crazy amount of reps, CrossFitters!). So the fix should be easy, right? Limit volume and you’ll avoid rhabdo in yourself or those you are training. While the answer is simple, implementation is not. There are certain factors inherent to the CrossFit setting that can make it challenging to avoid overdoing it with volume, but by no means impossible. Follow my logic below:

  • CrossFit gyms are businesses, and to survive, they must make money. To make money the clients must be happy. Clients are happy if they feel they are getting a good workout and seeing results. CrossFit workouts are (well, should be) relatively short most days. For short workouts to be effective, clients must train with high intensity.
  • CrossFit workouts are performed in groups, and in these groups are people of varying levels of fitness. Most clients do not know how to train with high intensity when they first start a CrossFit type program (think: years of long runs, back and biceps, and no longer in competitive sports). But some do. And that, my friends, is where the problem Dr. Eric Robertson highlighted in his article may have originated.

At the Level 1 CrossFit course, they teach the use of “time domains” as the primary way to program training intent, AND they encourage the use of “time caps” to preserve the training intent. The course also emphasizes that CrossFit workouts should predominantly fall in time domains under 16 minutes or so. This means the programmer chooses a timeframe, e.g. 4-6 minutes, that the workout should be performed, and then the athletes scale their loads given the movements involved and the time available. Time domains, time caps and short workouts are vitally important to effective CrossFit programming, and in my experience, this is where many CrossFit affiliates make mistakes. To understand why this can be an easy mistake to make, consider the following hypothetical programming scenario:

  • Imagine I am a CrossFit coach planning training for my clients. If I ask a beast-mode, fire-breathing athlete to perform a 4-minute workout, she will push herself to the limits of complete exhaustion. Effective programming = happy client = good business.
    On the other hand, if I ask the new client who has been riding the elliptical for 45 minutes, 3 nights a week for the past 5 years to do the same 4-minute workout, she will likely apply the level of intensity with which she is most familiar.
    When I force her to stop at 4 minutes to enforce the training intent I’ve programmed, she is going to be incredibly unhappy because she didn’t get as much out of it as the fire-breather. Ineffective programming= unhappy client = bad business.
  • If we ask these same two athletes to complete a 25-minute workout where they try to perform as many push-ups and shoulder presses as possible, we end up with a different outcome. We get a happy new client who feels she got her money’s worth and performed a safe amount of reps. Effective programming (in her mind), happy client, good business. On the other hand, we may get our fire-breathing bad ass with a raging case of rhabdo because she’s done 657 reps of 2 very similar movements. Ineffective (and injurious) programming, unhappy client, bad business.

The Point Is…

The Point Is...

Correct implementation of time caps and rest cycles are two excellent ways to teach and allow athletes to train with intensity safely. These tools prevent excessive volume and keep our athletes in training and out of the hospital.
Intensity leads to great training results. Intensity decreases over time, so long workouts are not as intense as short workouts (in average work output). Intensity is a skill that must be taught, most especially to folks who are used to long cardio and traditional strength training routines. Intervals with rest cycles would be an effective tool in this situation as the new athlete will realize that they have more to give on sequential intervals.

Timing workouts is a simple way of gauging intensity. Allowing clients or athletes to consistently work past the programmed “time domain” can result in that athlete never learning how to train with intensity. They will likely plateau on your program alarmingly soon as they essentially apply the same stimulus to their body day after day. Correct implementation of time caps and rest cycles are two excellent ways to teach and allow athletes to train with intensity safely. These tools prevent excessive volume and keep our athletes in training and out of the hospital.

While the new client/athlete may not appreciate the 4-minute workout their first week at the Box, they will be forced to learn the all-important skill of intensity and eventually understand why experienced CrossFit athletes dread Fran more than Murph.

It falls on the trainer and the programmer to teach and implement intensity into the workouts and in the end workouts are more effective, clients are happy, business is good and everyone is protected against rhabdo.

We recommend our colleagues in the musculoskeletal health and injury prevention professions step up to the challenge, become more involved with and educated on the topics they criticize, and seize this opportunity to make a difference by following some simple advice:

Whatever the problem, be part of the solution. Don’t just sit around raising questions and pointing out obstacles. We’ve all worked with the person. That person is a drag. -Tina Fey

For more info on intelligent programming refer to these earlier Back To The Box articles by Dr. Jared N. Williamson: Considerations and Why before How

Printable Version

We Are Scouting Top Writers

Are you passionate about fitness and have something to say? Reach a huge online community and get the discussion going - start writing for Tabata Times today!

Share this post
@TabataTimes on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook 

Contribute to this story by commenting below:

Advertise Here

Most Popular of All Time

Beaverton CrossFit posted an article
Beaverton CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit 101 shared a link on Facebook

http://crossfit101.com/waiting-exhale/

CrossFit Los Gatos posted an article
Berkeley CrossFit posted an article
mindcoach published the post Confidence and High Intensity Performance on Tabata Times
I know we just moved out of ski season, but skiing has so much to teach us about mental strength...
Morgan Hill CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

week5 wod4 http://wp.me/p3Bc8L-jj

CrossFitOfFremont posted an article
Berkeley CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit 101 posted an article
CrossFit Potrero Hill shared a link on Facebook

WOD- Thursday, July 3 SKILL OF THE MONTH: MUSCLE-UP Weekly Homework: do this before class, after class, or at open gym to improve your muscle ups! Week 7/1-7/6/14 1. Swing Hip to Rings 3×8 2. Ring Supports 3×8 3. Ring Rows 3×10 4. False Grip Hang 2x …

CrossFit Oakland posted on Facebook

Thursday is a Recovery Day!

Telegraph CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Thursday 7/3/2014 WOD http://www.telegraphcrossfit.com/thursday-732014/

Telegraph CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit Ashland posted an article
Beaverton CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Announcements Fourth of July schedule! Friday - 8:30 AM and 11:30 AM Saturday - 8:15 AM, 9:30 Burn, 12:00 PM Main - Mobility with Roskopf Guest Mobilizer this evening! This guy knows how to have a good time! View Public Whiteboard: http://bit.ly/1vzh78F Metcon (No Measure) Expect some smashing, rolling, twisting, turning, laughing, crying and overall goodness happening to your crusty tissues!

Max Fitness CrossFit posted on Facebook

7/3/14 Come in, work on a skill! Make up a WOD.

CrossFit Dark Element shared a link on Facebook

http://cfdarkelement.com/whiteboard/

CrossFit Dark Element shared a link on Facebook

http://cfdarkelement.com/daily-wod/

Beaverton CrossFit posted on Facebook

Mobility Thursday night. July 3rd. 6:30pm - guest/substitute mobilizer! This guy's gonna tear you apart! Have a blast gang! RWR.

CrossFit Sweatshop posted an article
San Carlos CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Oakdale shared a link on Facebook

http://cfoakdale.com/2014/07/03/kevins-climb-completed/

San Carlos CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Lots of snatches tomorrow #crossfit #snatch #fit #fitness #exercise #lift #wod #pr #crossfitgirls @mjett74

San Carlos CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Working on our base. #crossfit #rowing #fit #fitness #wod #lift #exercise @mmaclean01

Concord CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Welcome some new faces :-) great job tonight Courtney, John and Megan!!!

CrossFit West Santa Cruz shared a link on Facebook

Matt http://wp.me/suz1A-matt

CrossFit West Santa Cruz posted an article
Beaverton CrossFit posted on Facebook

Great work at the track tonight....tough session

CrossFit Potrero Hill posted an article
Beaverton CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Announcements Fourth of July schedule! Friday - 8:30 AM and 11:30 AM Saturday - 8:15 AM, 9:30 Burn, 12:00 PM Main - CrossFit View Public Whiteboard: http://bit.ly/TQiSCw Main WOD Around the World (No Measure) 5 movements @ 70% 1 min each for 30 min Olympic lifting Clean and Jerk (1 clean + jerk each 90s ; add 10# until fail ) Perform 1 clean + jerk each 90s, add 10# ; until fail...rest 5 min , repeat...try to meet or beat it Men start - 135 Women -95

Telegraph CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Working on Jerk Balances for warmups and position work in tonight's Weightlifting Class

CrossFit Mill Valley shared an image on Facebook

Worlds colliding to save lives. Juggling for Jude #poweredbymammoth

CrossFit West Santa Cruz posted on Facebook

Athletes, remember that the Firecracker Race will be running on July 4th at Harvey West. You'll need to park a couple blocks away and walk or run to the 9am class. :-)

CrossFit 209 Sport shared a link on Facebook

https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=735577119822185&id=163071317072771

CrossFit 209 Sport posted on Facebook

What will you be making for your 4th of July BBQ??? Let's hear it!! https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=410308475776149&substory_index=0&id=271313329675665

CrossFit 209 Sport shared an image on Facebook

https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=284606848385040&id=148284738683919 More info on knee pain!!

CrossFit 101 shared a link on Facebook

Scamper Pics are up!

CrossFit West Santa Cruz shared a link on Facebook

Super short read with great tips.

saulj shared a link on Facebook

Not saying anything, just saying...

San Carlos CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Back in action #thrusters #crossfit #fit #fitness #exercise #lift #wod

CrossFit Oakdale posted on Facebook

http://www.playbuzz.com/erikw/what-crossfit-exercise-are-you

CrossFit Cypher shared an image on Facebook

It's the new planking? AM crew helds it down!

CrossFit Cypher shared an image on Facebook

It's the new planking? AM crew helds it down!

CrossFit Cypher shared an image on Facebook

It's the new planking? AM crew helds it down!

CrossFit Cypher shared an image on Facebook

It's the new planking? AM crew helds it down!

CrossFit Cypher shared an image on Facebook

It's the new planking? AM crew helds it down!

CrossFit Los Gatos shared an image on Facebook

Noon class finishing strong today! Kb's, push jerks and C2b pull ups! Oh ya ;)

CrossFit Envy shared a link on Facebook

Oops, forgot to mention, use the link to sign up and help a brother out :-P.

CrossFit Envy shared a link on Facebook

Hey everyone! Inov-8's, along with Skins and CEP compression gear, and other great gear for CrossFit.

CrossFit Modesto posted on Facebook

Just a little FYI guys, Friday July 4th. Coach Chris will be in at 5:30am for a workout and Coach Billy will be in at 9am as well! These are the only two classes for Friday, so prepare for some fun!

CrossFit Davis shared a link on Facebook

Make Coach Elliot happy and sign up for the Tommy Kono Meet coming up in August! There are sign up sheets at the gym! Talk to Elliot or any other coach for more info!

Arena Ready CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Couldn't ask for a better athlete, coach, and friend to join us at Arena Ready! Too bad she's a Seahawks fan - I guess no one is perfect.

Tamalpais CrossFit posted on Facebook

July Happenings: Friday July 4th- 8 & 9am Classes only! Sunday July 6th- 9am Swim WOD at COM Kentfield Pool Sunday July 6th- Oly Strong moves to 10:15am on Sundays Tuesday July 8th- 11-11:45am CrossFit Kids starts, 2 spots left, register today! Parents WOD while your kid plays! Saturday July 12th- Crosstown Throwdown TCF vs Santa Rosa Strength and Conditioning – 11:45-2 pm at TCF, sign up on competition board located in SRB- all levels welcome! July 21st- Clarke Holland attends and dominates the CrossFit Games 2014

FTF Fitness posted an article
CrossFit Sandpoint shared an image on Facebook

We're officially announcing our High Performance Lifting Seminar with 2x Junior National Champion Phillip Wilhelm! EVENT OVERVIEW: Phillip Wilhelm (USAW High Performance Athlete) will be taking CrossFit athletes through a two day technique and development training camp that will give each athlete enough time to work on the basics while progressively advancing to more complex movements. This two day training camp covers the snatch and clean and jerk. Each day will start with a progressive introduction of lifts and overview of essentials. There will be mobility exercises and stretching before coaches coaching movements and exercises. Athletes should expect to be working with light low volume reps. This will enable athletes to focus extensively on motor pattern work and refinement of the bar path. Spots are limited, so if you would like to be apart of this epic weekend you can register and pay one of three ways: 1. http://hplifting.dov3webs.com/events/2014/08/crossfit-sandpoint-seminar/ 2. Put your name on the list next to the whiteboard in the gym 3. Email or call me to set up payment option. (kenny@crossfitsandpoint(dot)com) Early Registration (before July 21st at 9:00pm) is $195 Late Registration (after July 21st at 9:01pm) is $250 If you aren't already sold, here are some things to consider: - This is an insanely inexpensive seminar. I generally expect to pay at least $400-$500 for two days (and have paid a heck of a lot more). This one breaks down to be about $20 an hour with one of the top weightlifters in the United States. And, super bonus, you don't even have to travel. - On average, our normal classes spend roughly 20-30 minutes a day, two days a week working on the Snatch and/or Clean & Jerk. In other words, we only spend a total of an hour a week working on extremely technical lifts that take a lifetime to master. These 8-10 dedicated hours will improve your technique by leaps and bounds. - This is for athletes of all levels. Don't be intimidated if you feel like you're a beginner. You won't be holding anyone up. In fact, you probably stand to benefit the most of anyone. - It's not often that a coach/lifter of this caliber comes through the Inland Northwest, let alone Sandpoint. Take advantage. - This is open to the public, and spots are limited, so sign up fast. If you have any questions, don't hesitate to ask.

CrossFit Petaluma posted on Facebook

Schedule for the week of July 4th: Friday, July 4th: 10am class @ CSC only Saturday, July 5th: 10am class @ CSC only Make your way up to CrossFit Sonoma County to pick a Hero workout to complete in honor of Independence Day! The gym will be open from 10am-11:30am. Come in and throw down before a day filled with food, family, and fireworks!

Berkeley CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit 209 Sport posted on Facebook

4th of July hours 8 and 9 AM only!!

bevchildress published the post Do You Struggle With Chronic Disease? on
I live with Rheumatoid Arthritis Disease. I’ve done a pretty good job of keeping it at bay and...

@TabataTimes on Twitter

Watch the latest episode of GPTV