Are Heavy Kettlebell Swings Better Than Deadlifts?

Love to Eat? Introducing

Are you passionate about food, nutrition and recipes? Unleash your inner foodie and check out our brand-new site - share your favorite recipes at Nutrition-WOD today!

Page:  1 Next »
Print

Are Heavy Kettlebell Swings Better Than Deadlifts?
Picking up heavy things off the ground is foundational not only to CrossFit training, but to daily routines as well. We regularly bend at the hips to pick things up or tie our shoes, thus a more conditioned posterior chain is imperative for spinal health and longevity.

For this very reason, the deadlift is a staple in almost all training programs.

However, despite its efficacy in strengthening the posterior chain, among other things it is also notorious for catalyzing CNS fatigue, making it impractical for frequent implementation at the heavier loads demanded for adaptation. (Read our article on CNS fatigue and our article on overtraining here)

Are there feasible alternatives you can incorporate in lieu of heavy deadlifts? According to leading industry trainer Bret Contreras, there are: heavy kettlebell swings. Find out why (for more on this topic, read our article on How To Improve Your Kettlebell Swing).

The kettlebell swing is an incredible exercise, but it’s also quite polarizing, as strength coaches seem to either love it or hate it.

I’ve spoken to coaches in America, Europe, Australia, New Zealand, and Canada, and I always get the same two opinions.

The international consensus

I can understand both sides of the equation. What the coaches with the latter opinion fail to realize is that the hip extension torque requirements of a lighter kettlebell swing can indeed match that of a heavier clean or snatch, due to the inherent arced motion of the kettlebell.
It’s either something like, “I love the kettlebell swing, it’s a great tool for teaching proper hip movement and for conditioning the glutes and hamstrings,” or something like, “The kettlebell swing sounds good in theory, but my athletes need heavier loads to induce adaptations. Therefore I’ll keep squatting and power cleaning.”

You must absorb eccentric loading and then reverse the kettlebell forward and upward, whereas in the case of the Olympic pulls you simply accelerate the barbell upward and then catch it up top.

For this reason, the classic argument suggesting that power outputs of kettlebell swings can’t match those of power cleans and snatches isn’t accurate, but you must take into account the resultant (horizontal and vertical) data to realize this.

However, I agree with the premise that a 35-pound kettlebell won’t do much for increasing a lineman’s hip strength – heavier loads are indeed needed as they lead to greater force production, which is always important! But force isn’t the only variable important in sports, power is a critical component, and the swing is an excellent movement for hip power.

Perfect Swing Form: You Know it When You See It

You know good form when you see it

First, I’d like to discuss kettlebell swing form. I’m sure the RKC folks have scrutinized every last detail about the swing and have come up with the best possible way of teaching it. And since I’m not RKC-certified, I’m not quite as qualified as those folks to discuss kettlebell swing form.

However, I’m obsessed with biomechanics and a student of movement in general. And for this reason, I know a perfect kettlebell swing when I see it. There’s a certain beauty to the motion that’s hard to describe.

Watch this video of my friend Marianne and you’ll understand:

Here are some general rules you want to be aware of:

  • A proper set up (sort of like a center hiking a football) is with high hips, a solid arch, and the kettlebell out in front to allow for proper “hiking” of the first rep.
  • The feet stay planted firmly on the ground – there’s no rising onto the toes.
  • The movement’s emphasis isn’t on sinking down into a squat, but rather on hinging around the hips. There’s a considerable range of motion around the hip joint with the torso position nearly parallel to the ground at the bottom range of motion.
  • On the way down, the lifter shifts his weight forward a bit and the knees bend and travel forward slightly. On the way up, an explosive hip action characterized by a strong gluteal contraction raises the kettlbell upwards and the lifter shifts his weight backward a bit.
  • While the kettlebell is near the body, it stays close to the “privates” and never sinks below the knees.
  • A neutral spine (no lumbar flexion at the bottom or hyperextension at the top of the movement) position is maintained with very slight anterior pelvic tilt at the bottom of the motion and very slight posterior pelvic tilt at the top.
  • The posterior pelvic tilt and glute contraction is maintained while the kettlebell travels upward and away from the body and is held until the kettlebell drops back down and returns near the body.
  • There’s no excessive contribution from the arms; for the most part the hips drive the kettlebell to its peak height, which is around shoulder-level.
  • A neutral neck position (no cervical hyperextension) is maintained throughout the movement.
  • The goal isn’t to learn how to use momentum and conserve energy – it’s easy to figure out how to “cheat” during the swing. Rather, the goal is to achieve a maximal glute contraction to drive the kettlebell forward and upward explosively while adhering to excellent technical form.

Show Me Someone Who Can Swing Properly and I’ll Show You Someone Who Can Squat, Deadlift, and Hip Thrust Properly

How swinging properly can help in other areas

Talk to any coach or trainer and they’ll tell you some horror stories about “nightmare” athletes or clients who showed up on their doorsteps with the worst lumbopelvic-hip-complex (LPHC) kinematics known to mankind.

I’ve trained a few of these folks myself. They’re unable to keep a neutral spine while bending. Tell them to sit back and they coil over like a snake. They don’t possess the motor control to stabilize the spine while moving solely around the hip joint. It can take weeks just to get them to hip hinge properly. With these clients, you must improve their movement patterns before loading them up, so patience is needed.

For this reason, when someone shows up to train with me and they have proper kettlebell training experience, I’m ecstatic. If they can swing properly, it’s quite easy to teach them how to squat, deadlift, and hip thrust properly.

They already possess superior motor control in the LPHC characterized by proper hip hinging form and proper gluteal contraction at lockout. These qualities exemplify most of the more complex components of the big lower body lifts.

Think about the typical cues used by coaches during squats and deadlifts: “Sit back,” “knees out,” “chest up,” “push through the heels,” “squeeze the glutes,” and “keep the neck in neutral.” Good kettlebell swingers are already doing all of these.

So, with plenty of practice on the preceding biomechanics, heavy ass kettle bell swings can provide the same benefits to strength and conditioning as maximal deadlifts, but without the feeling of being destroyed subsequently.

Inherent Ground Reaction Forces Involved in 2 Styles of Kettlebell Swings

The styles of kettlebell swings

When I was in Auckland, New Zealand, I conducted a minor experiment. I used two different loads (70 pounds and 140 pounds) and performed two different styles of swings (a squat style swing and a hip-hinge style swing) while standing on a force plate.

To the naked eye, the differences in form between the two appear very subtle, but in terms of kinematics and kinetics they’re quite different. In the squat style, the kettlebell sinks down more, the knees bend more, and the torso stays slightly more upright, but in the hip style swing, the emphasis is on hip hinging (see Marianne’s hip range of motion).

Style   Load(lbs)   Peak Vertical Force(N)      Peak Horizontal Force(N)
Squat Style 70 2,170-2,349 166-182
Squat Style 140 2,431-2,444 278-353
Hip Hinge Style 70 1,935-2,140 340-402
Hip Hinge Style 140 2,325-2,550 499-520
Printable Version
Page 1 2 Next »

We Are Scouting Top Writers

Are you passionate about fitness and have something to say? Reach a huge online community and get the discussion going - start writing for Tabata Times today!

Share this post
@TabataTimes on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook 

Contribute to this story by commenting below:

Advertise Here

Most Popular of All Time

Front Range CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Front Range CrossFit had a fantastic 2 days of Olympic Weightlifting down in Colorado Springs at the Rocky Mountain State Games this past weekend. Congratulations to all of our lifters. You worked so hard for this and lifted so well. We are so proud of you. Ryan Dritein made 5 of his 6 lifts, achieving a personal record (PR) in the snatch at 66kg, a PR in the C&J at 95kg, and a PR in the total at 161kg. Teralyn Carter went 6 for 6 (meaning she made all of her lifts) which is very impressive since she had PR's in all 3 categories as well. The snatch at 54kg, the C&J at 74kg, and the total at 128kg. Teralyn took Gold in the 63kg open division. Josh Guillen went 5 for 6 and PR'd all his lifts and total with a snatch of 80kg, C&J of 114, and total of 194. Dave Loudenslager also PR'd all of his lifts and total with a snatch of 75kg, C&J of 104, and total of 179. Amy Backel lifted next. And yes... She PR'd all of her lifts and total too! She snatched 76kg, C&J 96, and totaled 172. This was enough to give her a Gold metal in the 75kg Open division. Owen Shearer was our last lifter. Yes... He too went 6 for 6 and PR'd all of his lifts! Snatch 93kg, C&J 116kg, and total 209kg (no straps). In addition to the lifters above we had some of our old members come back and lift under our Club. Paula Schoettinger took 1st place in the 53kg open division, Martin Wolfe won 1st place in the 69kg open division, and Kalee Noe took 1st in the 69kg youth division.

CrossFit Undeniable shared an image on Facebook

In honor of USAF SSgt Timothy P. Davis, 28, who was killed on Feburary, 20 2009 supporting operations in OEF when his vehicle was struck by an IED. Timothy is survived by his wife Megan and one-year old son T.J. 3 x M.E. Strict Pull Up then.. "DT" 5 Rounds For Time Of: 155 pound Deadlift, 12 reps 155 pound Hang power clean, 9 reps 155 pound Push jerk, 6 reps

Front Range CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Keshara Bjorkman published the post Sorry I Dripped My Face Sweat in The Chalk Bucket on Tabata Times
It’s been a minute since I’ve been ashamed of my sweat. I remember the days of high school...
Ketchikan CrossFit posted an article
Front Range CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Mat-Su CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Adventure shared an image on Facebook

WOD for 7.28.14 and 8:30am classes http://crossfitadventure.com/wod-7-28-14/

CrossFit Adventure posted an article
CrossFit Refinery posted an article
Big Horn CrossFit posted on Facebook

WOD 7/28/14 STRENGTH Complete the following, NOT for time: 1 round of: 10 Clean & Jerks @ 40% 1 round of: 10 Clean & Jerks @ 50% 1 round of: 10 Clean & Jerks @ 60% *Rest as needed between sets WORKOUT For time: 15 Clean & Jerks @ 65% *3-min cap

CrossFit Fairbanks shared an image on Facebook

Brethren CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

This woman rocks!!

Brethren CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

4 time champ!!

CrossFit Verve posted on Facebook

New WOD: “Double 2′s” For time: Row 2000M 200 double unders Run 2 miles Post time to BTW. Have fun on that 2k row today! Rowing Primer by Colby Knepp Most people loathe rowing. I LOVE rowing. Partly because it’s a pretty simple movement, but mostly because rowing is all about w...... Click for more: http://www.crossfitverve.com/?p=16080

CrossFit Fairbanks shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit Prestige posted on Facebook

492 (7/28/14) Teams of 2 2 Rounds 50 Handstand Push Ups 50 Box Jumps #30"/24" 50 Squat Cleans #135/95 100 Double Unders / 300 Singles Buy Out: 800m Run

mindcoach published the post The Importance of Self-Talk For Peak Performance on
I’ve discussed in several posts the importance and affect self-talk can have not only on your...
Boise CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Lots of neat vendors here. Ordered you this fun toy for muscle up practice Boise CrossFit!

CrossFit Deco shared an image on Facebook

Solid Sunday at #crossfitdeco #potluck #running #opengym #yoga #crossfit #theseareafewofmyfavoritethings

MBS Crossfit shared an image on Facebook

The few weeks leading up to The CrossFit Games were a bit stressful for Pat Burke as his biggest fan, wife Janelle, went into preterm labor. Mandatory bed rest has prevented her from being at The Games but she and their unborn son are making some noise from the hospital room in Denver!! #pfb #familyfirst #babyburke

Boise CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

It's official, 8th place finish at the 2014 CrossFit Games!!

Boise CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

We love you guys and could not be more proud of your effort!

CrossFit Roots posted on Facebook

The team finals are on now! Come on by this afternoon for the conclusion of the individual competition. The Midline March kicks off at 1:30 Mountain Time and the Finals start at 4pm. https://games.crossfit.com/schedule

Boise CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Just some of the Boise CrossFit fan support. Please tag yourselves

CrossFit 305 posted on Facebook

If you're not watching the Games, you're crazy! Man, we love this stuff. Post your training goals for the coming year below:

CrossFit Dojo shared a link on Facebook

http://www.livestrong.org/events/1800/ Here it is folks! C'mon, lets do this! When you register,join our Team- CrossFit Dojo

Boise CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Tied for first on the team 50's chipper and moved into 7th with just the final event to go!

julianhooks published the post Natural Weight Loss with the Help of Qi Medicine on
Did you know that one of the most common problems faced today is obesity? And sadly, the fast food...
MBS Crossfit shared an image on Facebook

MBS Crossfit shared an image on Facebook

GWOD!

MBS Crossfit shared an image on Facebook

GWOD!

MBS Crossfit shared an image on Facebook

GWOD!

MBS Crossfit shared an image on Facebook

GWOD!

MBS Crossfit shared an image on Facebook

GWOD!

Boise CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

I wasn't fast enough to get a picture, Caleb went unbroken on the wallballs!

Boise CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Start of day 3!

CrossFit Dojo shared an image on Facebook

Way to go all you CFD Athletes and Friends who came out to take advantage of the opportunity to get some coaching at the pool this morning! Remember to pick up your Dynamo Swim Pass if you want to have access to the pool for lap swimming! Also- remember to sign up for Eric Shanteau's Swim for Your Life! REGISTER

CrossFit Dojo shared an image on Facebook

Saturday was a good day for endurance!

CrossFit Refinery posted an article
MBS Crossfit shared an image on Facebook

Coach Amy knows what's up!!!! It's selfie Sunday peeps! Put on your MBS gear, take a pic, and post it on our page!

MBS Crossfit shared an image on Facebook

We were able to spend time with Pat last night and provide him with some CF Games spectating humor. He's ready to give it his all on the final day of The CrossFit Games! He'll do the Midline March at 12:30 PST Let's make some noise! #pfb

CrossFit Deco posted on Facebook

Lots happening at DeCO today! - 11am yoga - 12-2 open gym - 12pm games viewing party and pot luck - 1-2pm running clinic

CrossFit San Jose posted on Facebook

ok, so Games coverage doesn't start for a while, come in to the Sunday class. See you at 8:30 AM.

CrossFit Roots posted on Facebook

Are you looking for a place to watch the final day of The Games? We'll have it on the big screen at Roots all day!

CrossFit Station shared a link on Facebook

Let's Represent!

Sledge CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit Games 2014

CrossFit Smyrna posted on Facebook

Andy is doing 3 bars of death (Linda) at 4 pm Sunday, today. Who wants to join him?

CrossFit 757 shared a link on Facebook

Sunday Funday : Sunday Funday

CrossFit 757 posted an article
Patriot CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Huge congratulations to PCF OG’s LeeAnn and Dave Gedeon on the birth of their daughter, Olivia, on Saturday! Addison can’t wait to teach her how to lift. RX’d Level II...

Patriot CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Interested in improving your Olympic Weightlifting? Drop-in to the Patriot CrossFit Weightlifting Club by clicking here. PCF Oly meets every Sunday from 6pm-8pm. ____________ Warmup: EMOTM 8 Min 3 Snatch Balance 3 V-Situp Alt: 3 Strict Pullup/3 …

CrossFit Perimeter shared an image on Facebook

Photos from our Saturday at the games. One more day left.

CrossFit Rx posted an article
CrossFit Rosslyn shared a link on Facebook

Sunday, 7/27/14:

Carolina CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit Rosslyn posted an article
CrossFit Old Town shared an image on Facebook

Hudson Jude Schwartz, born on July 24th at 4:05pm. Weighing 6lb 15.5 oz and 19.25inch long. Congrats Adam and Kelly!!!

CrossFit Woodbridge posted an article
CrossFit Pittsburgh posted an article

@TabataTimes on Twitter

Watch the latest episode of GPTV