Ask the Doc: Do You Know WHY You’re Icing?

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Print
by MISSY ALBRECHT, DPT, CSCS, FMS| Physical Therapist/Coach

Ask the Doc: Do You Know WHY You're Icing?

“Healthy athletes should be better at clearing inflammation in the body than ice.” – Dr. Kelly Starrett DPT
Using ice has grown into a big debate: Is it helpful, harmful, or just a placebo? In the end, the answer is…well, it depends. But I see a lot of our athletes icing after the workouts, so I want to make sure you know WHY you are icing so you can decide if it’s helping you, harming you, or is useless.

What are the main reasons people ice? Usually to calm swelling/inflammation, to numb pain, and “to make sure I don’t hurt after a workout” (a.k.a pain prevention). We will get into whether ice helps those things, but let’s start with what icing does to the body physiologically.

The Body’s Physiologic Response to Ice: Strictly the Facts. [1]

When ice is applied to the body, the cold acts to vasoconstrict (narrow) the blood vessels. This causes reduced blood flow to the area, stopping swelling/inflammation. The cold sensation also affects the brain by blocking pain signals that may have been being sent to the brain from the injured area.

lymphatic-system-benefits-from-rebounding

Important side note: take note of where the nodes are located and make sure you’re not jamming lacrosse balls, barbells or any other mobility tools really hard into these areas. Those areas don’t like aggressive mobility, so be nice to them.

What is Swelling? [2]

Inflammation is a GOOD RESPONSE TO INJURY. We want it. We need it. Inflammation is the body’s way of sending help to the injured area so that it can heal.
Swelling is an accumulation of fluid, mixed with good things and bad things (waste) from the injury. The joints, muscles and lymphatic system help to take the fluid back into the heart to flush it out of our system. Swelling becomes an issue when joints, muscles and the lymphatic system don’t work properly and when we are sedentary and/or in pain.

We’ve all been injured right? Either the pain stops us from moving, or we think that we shouldn’t move because we need to let our bodies heal. So we sit with _____ body part supported and don’t move; although we want to move, the pain is too much to handle. Consequently, we end up sedentary, thus allowing the waste product of swelling to accumulate — this leads to tissue damage and slow/no healing. This is why movement is so important: it allows for the evacuation of the fluid from the injured area back to the heart where the body can help dispose of it through the lymphatic system.

swollen-ankle

This ankle has some major accumulation of inflammatory fluids that need to be flushed out. This will not be accomplished by only ice-elevation-compression band. It needs movement too.

Why Icing May Have Negative Effects

Ice can definitely help with pain. It can also be used to help athletes recover when used in an ice bath during the 30 minutes following a tough workout/event.
Inflammation is a GOOD RESPONSE TO INJURY. We want it. We need it. Inflammation is the body’s way of sending help to the injured area so that it can heal. If ice is stopping inflammation, then why the heck are we using it when we want healing to occur? In theory, when we ice we are stopping a normal healing process in the body, even though our body is equipped with the necessary tools to be able to heal itself. This is the source of the more recent debate on icing and the reason why NSAIDs are not recommended (because they also stop good inflammation, along with causing other internal damage).

Something to also keep in mind, said by a very smart man:

“Healthy athletes should be better at clearing inflammation in the body than ice.” – Dr. Kelly Starrett DPT

We were engineered to have inflammation and heal without external aids. We need the help when we are unhealthy; when we are unable to rest long enough to recover from the injury; or when we continue to push through injury and cause more damage and excess/chronic inflammation.

When Icing May Still Be Helpful

Ice can definitely help with pain. It can also be used to help athletes recover when used in an ice bath during the 30 minutes following a tough workout/event. Research is touchy on this subject, which you can read a little about here and here on our blog. Contrast baths can also be beneficial (alternating ice and heat) to flush out the accumulation of fluid.

Alternatives To Icing

My Opinion

[I]cing for pain is okay, but only if you are doing something on the side to help figure out what is causing the pain and modifying as needed while it heals.
Ok, I know it’s all throughout this blog already, but I figured it would be a nice recap. I don’t think icing is terrible, but I do think twice about it before I use it or tell someone to use it now. I tell people to ice if they can’t bear the pain because I think it’s better than using medications, but I also make sure they are doing something to get the joint and muscles moving! I don’t think it will do terrible damage at the time of use, but repetitive use of ice could definitely slow healing and alter proper healing overall.

My main issue, which brought up this blog topic in the first place, is with those who ice after every workout. I do believe this could cause more damage than help, primarily because it is not allowing for proper healing after the workouts. The exception would be if you did a rockstar workout/competition and need the ice for the ice bath recovery theory described above. Secondly, I think many people are using it to help for pain relief from the workout or because they assume it will be painful later. I said earlier that icing for pain is okay, but only if you are doing something on the side to help figure out what is causing the pain and modifying as needed while it heals. “It” won’t heal and go away if you just keep icing it. So if you’re someone who does ice after workouts, make sure you know WHY and whether or not you’re doing it for the right reasons.

References

1. http://www.cet-cryotherapy.com/cryotherapy_physiologic_effect.html

2. Kelly Starrett’s video on how icing is bad

3. Tricia J. Hubbard and Craig R. Denegar. Does Cryotherapy Improve Outcomes With Soft Tissue Injury?J Athl Train. 2004 Jul-Sep; 39(3): 278–279

4. http://www.marksdailyapple.com/should-we-ice-injuries/#axzz2dOIKNd00 

Printable Version

We Are Scouting Top Writers

Are you passionate about fitness and have something to say? Reach a huge online community and get the discussion going - start writing for Tabata Times today!

Share this post
@TabataTimes on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook 

Contribute to this story by commenting below:

Advertise Here

Most Popular of All Time

astewart30 published the post Size Doesn't Matter on Tabata Times
From the time I was 10 years old I have been aware of my size. I have always known how much I weigh...
CrossFit KSX posted on Facebook

Tuesday's Workout Strength: 10 min EMOM 3 Deadlift @ 70% of 3RM Conditioning: 12min EMOM 3 Power cleans 155/115 5 strict pull-ups Rest 2 min: 3 rounds of: 1 min elbow plank 45 sec max supermans 30 sec Russian twist with weight 20/15 * 30 sec rest between rounds*

CrossFit Center City shared a link on Facebook

#DIDYOUKNOW that CFCC offers Custom Fit Meals? These fresh, healthy meals are a great option for weeks when you're especially busy. They offer a huge menu that rotates week to week, and there's no commitment required. Use code CENTERCITY to take 10% off your first order. If you're thinking about participating in the #cfccrecharge or are struggling to find healthy options on-the-go, give CFM a try! #nutrition #paleo #paleoish http://crossfitcc.com/a-new-option-for-healthy-convenient-eats-at-cfcc/

CrossFit Center City shared an image on Facebook

Don't forget we are holding a 2 hour introductory Strongman clinic on Sunday September 28th. Link to sign up is in the comments. Email Record at record@crossfitcc.com if you have any questions about it and remember it is open to both CFCC member and non-members!

Kristy Parrish published the post How Julie Foucher Became Julie Foucher on
Editor's Note: "How Julie Foucher Became Julie Foucher" was originally posted to the Beyond the...
WhatWouldJohnMackEat published the post Portuguese Style Littleneck Clams on Nutrition WOD
Littleneck clams are hands down my favorite seafood. I eat them raw, steamed or cooked Portuguese...
Breaking Point Fitness CrossFit Ridge Ave posted on Facebook

Tuesday 9/9/14 15 mins to work to heavy Snatch deadlift + snatch pull + snatch For time: 10 power cleans 185/125 20 burpee over bar 30 toe 2 bar 200ft farmers carry 55/35 30 toe 2 bar 20 burpee over bar 10 power cleans

CrossFit Center City shared a link on Facebook

Learn all about the newest cycle leading up to the CrossFit Total on Halloween! Deadlift and Strict Press Tuesday tomorrow! http://crossfitcc.com/workout-of-the-day-tuesday-9-9-14/

CrossFit RDU shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Invoke shared an image on Facebook

Body Comp Challenge is in full swing. Be sure to make these next 12 weeks worth it! #cfinvoke #cfiathlete #cfibootycamp #crossfit #bodycomp #fat #relentlesslife #weighin #eatright #nutrition #goals #progress

CrossFit King of Prussia posted an article
CrossFit RDU posted an article
CrossFit Gastonia shared a link on Facebook

Tuesday's WOD http://www.crossfitgastonia.com/w-o-d

CrossFit Delaware Valley shared an image on Facebook

6pm cleanin' and dubbin'!

CrossFit Delaware Valley shared an image on Facebook

N'Sync! (See what I did there? Lol)

Breaking Point Fitness CrossFit Ridge Ave shared a link on Facebook

There is still space left to register for the Carl Paoli seminar at CrossFit Ridge Ave on September 20th from 9am-5pm. The seminar is $295 with discounts offered for CF Level 1 Certified Trainers, Educators, Military/Fire/Police/Rescue and USA Gymnastics members! https://freestyleconnection.pushpress.com/open/event/freestyle-connection-seminar---philadelphia-pa

CrossFit 77 shared an image on Facebook

What an awesome start to our Let's Move class on Saturday September 6! Remember this class is free every Saturday from 10:30-11:30 bring your kids and their friends! We can't wait to see the turn out for this Saturday!

CrossFit 77 posted on Facebook

George just PR'd his back squat by 50lbs! 365# like a champ!

CrossFit Wake Forest posted on Facebook

9/9/2014 WOD: Push Press 3-3-3-3-3 Use the heaviest weight you can for each set. Rest as needed between sets. Then: 4 rounds for time of: Run, 200 m 10 Kettlebell Swings

CrossFit Wilmington posted an article
CrossFit Harrisburg posted on Facebook

Tues Back Squat (3x4 @ 80%, then 1 set for max reps) 15 mins to complete Metcon (Time) 4 Rounds 200m Run 40 double unders 300m Row Rest 1 min 2 for 1 du subs

CrossFit Invoke posted an article
CrossFit Main Line posted an article
CrossFit Main Line posted an article
CrossFit Main Line posted an article
CrossFit Main Line posted an article
Raleigh CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit Wilmington shared an image on Facebook

Everyone loves HSPUs @cfwilmington #wantmoredomore #strongereveryday

CrossFit LKN shared an image on Facebook

Big 9 am class this morning!

CrossFit Love shared a link on Facebook

9.9.14 http://bit.ly/1tFrlIx

CrossFit Love shared an image on Facebook

The Olympic Weightlifting seminar with Diane Fu is almost here! Have you registered?! Learn more about the Olympic lifts and what mistakes you may be making that are holding your PRs back! Check out the details and register TODAY! http://bit.ly/NtByob

CrossFit Wilmington shared an image on Facebook

Great job to Alison and all of our new members this summer!

judyjudyjudy published the post Why The Box Is Not Like Any Old Gym- Facing Fear and Finding Beauty At Crossfit on
"He has not learned the lesson of life who does not every day surmount a fear. " ~Ralph Waldo...
Raleigh CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit Main Line shared an image on Facebook

Beginning this week, YOGA will be offered at 10:30am on Tuesdays at CFML and Thursdays at CFR5. Come join us!

CrossFit Durham posted on Facebook

Welcome back to CFD athlete, and recent new MOM, Rachel Mason!

CrossFit RDU shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit RDU shared an image on Facebook

We will have WODbody Sports Massage in house here at CrossFit RDU this coming Wednesday. Appointment slots will be available from 3pm-8pm in 30min sessions or more. There will be a sign up sheet on the whiteboard. Check them out and we may make it a permanent fixture! $35 - 30 minutes $45 - 40 minutes $55 - 50 minutes $65 - 60 minutes

CrossFit RDU posted an article
CrossFit Exchange shared an image on Facebook

Achieving Excellence through competition helps us break through our own boundaries. From the coaches desk we are all proud of the athletes that came out, and more importantly for all of your help and support.

CrossFit Delaware Valley shared an image on Facebook

Ladies - check this out!

CrossFit Durham shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit 910 shared an image on Facebook

liftlaugheatrepeat published the post Secret Ingredient Paleo Meatloaf on
So my husband absolutely loves meatloaf, which is great because it's a relatively simple meal...
CrossFit Main Line shared a link on Facebook

Hey Main Liners and R5ers! Good news...beginning this Thursday, 9.11 at 6:30pm we are bringing in a Chiropractor a couple days a week for your aches, pains and general fitness recovery needs to CFML. The wonderful, Dr. Katzen will be scheduling free consultations and following up with necessary treatments. We could all use a little adjustment. Call today to schedule your appointment at CFML- 610-664-8330 http://www.drkatzen.com/

CrossFit Coastal shared an image on Facebook

Congratulations to Brandon M for passing his CrossFit Level 1 Certification and also Head Coaches Phil & Kelly for completing / passing their CrossFit Kettlebell Certification this weekend! Continuing education is very important to us here at CrossFit Coastal. Your instructors are always in a constant state of learning new ways to serve you better. Proud of you!

CrossFit Harrisburg shared an image on Facebook

No heel strike.

CrossFit 919 posted on Facebook

Endurance WOD tonight at 6:30 PM. We'll be inside on the rowers.

CrossFit Durham posted on Facebook

Wishing Greg Wehn a very HAPPY BIRTHDAY!

CrossFit Durham posted an article
CrossFit Durham shared an image on Facebook

Check out CFD athlete, Sarah Tallent, in our latest Athlete Spotlight! "My body has much more muscle than before. I like that part. I also really like feeling strong. I never feel more strong than when my hands are around a barbell preparing for a 1 rep max of something." www.crossfitdurham.com/sarah-tallent

CrossFit LKN posted on Facebook

This Wednesday, September 10th from 6:30-8:00pm Kyle will be holding a Nutrition Seminar. It is free and open to anyone who would like to attend (members or non-members). If you haven't attended one of Kyle's nutrition seminars definitely get in for this one!

CrossFit 77 shared a link on Facebook

11 Reasons Dehydration Is Making You Sick & Fat http://themindunleashed.org/2014/09/11-reasons-dehydration-making-sick-fat.html

CrossFit Durham posted on Facebook

Congratulations to our newest Foundations Course graduates, Ali Giusto and Sam Matias! Welcome to CFD!

CrossFit Exchange shared an image on Facebook

What a day!

CrossFit Main Line shared an image on Facebook

R5s Monday morning 6am crew 1RM Front Squat with 3sec pause Then, 1000m Row 50 Wall Balls 30 Pull Ups

Oak City CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit Silver Spring posted an article
CrossFit WhiteMarsh shared a link on Facebook

Monday WOD

CrossFit Dilworth posted on Facebook

CFE Week of 9.8.14: 9/8: 4 Rds: 2min each of row, burpees, DU. 1 min rest btw each. Then, core work. 9/10: 25 Min AMRAP of 400M Run w/ max plank hold. Once runner can no longer hold plank they must run again. Then, 5 Min hill sprints every 30 sec.

@TabataTimes on Twitter

Watch the latest episode of GPTV