Cheating or Honest Hard Work

Print

As a self declared pull up junkie, I have always been a bit surprised at the ongoing and spirited nature of the debate over kipping vs. regular pull ups. At the core of the conversation seems to be the question about which one is better than the other?

I had to think twice before electing to add my view on the topic. After all, there are serious critics and strong advocates who have taken sides one way or the other. Critics say kipping is cheating and still others advance that the stress placed on the muscles can have real negative side effects. I don’t pretend to be a fitness expert, just an active participant. My views are a result of personal experience and after a little thought decided to jump right in anyway.

The kipping pull up involves a hip snap generating momentum that moves up the spine and into the arms. This lets you lift your body over the bar with less direct pulling. The result is a lot more pull ups. The strict pull up by comparison requires that the body stays rigid and only the joints needed to perform the movement come into play. Dead hang pull ups isolate muscles in the back and and arms while kipping pull ups are a full body exercise. While easier on the direct pulling muscles, they are much harder on the grip and are inarguably more cardiovascular.

Ok, so why the debate over which one is better? I don’t recall any rules posted on the gym wall that says I must do a pull up one way or the other. Are the pull up police on the look out? The idea that doing one variety instead of the other is cheating simply makes no sense to me. Intention and desired benefit seems to be the only appropriate qualifiers here. During my regular work outs, there are days when I’ll do weighted heavy pull ups and others where L- pull ups create the challenge for the day. If I kip while performing these exercises, I suppose I would be cheating myself of the intended advantages. Conversely, if the WOD calls for high volume kipping pull ups and I choose to perform the regular variety instead, I will miss out on the full benefit of the total body, high intensity workout that was programmed.

It wasn’t long ago that I had started working out with a new partner. Because we were so evenly matched in so many ways, our workouts tended to be intense and a little competitive; a perfect situation. He trusted me to program our workouts and I always felt bad about selecting a WOD that included high volume pull up work since he definitely was not the owner of a consistent kip. I recall a day where the classic Crosffit WOD, “Murph” was the workout of choice. I of course, tackled the 100 pull up reps by kipping. My friend completed the work with regular pull up attempts, slowly shifting more toward kipping as the set progressed since maintaining strict form becomes really hard. Did either one of us cheat that day?

What I know is that we both worked really hard……. Obviously, I was able to finish the pull ups quicker, but he made up all of the time on the squats. He has a definite edge on me when it comes to lower body strength and he pushed himself that much harder to ensure we were both heading out the door for the last mile run together.

In my view, pull ups are king, no matter what version you practice. All you really need is the personal will and a pull up bar. The desired benefits vary and doing just one variety exclusively is the only real “cheating” that should enter this conversation. As for honest hard work; you bet…. my friend made this point for me perfectly clear on Friday!

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Printable Version

We Are Scouting Top Writers

Are you passionate about fitness and have something to say? Reach a huge online community and get the discussion going - start writing for Tabata Times today!

Share this post
@TabataTimes on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook 
Advertise Here

Most Popular of All Time

luckytamm published the post 3 Things CrossFit Teaches You on Tabata Times
As a CrossFitter, over time it can be easy to overlook the nuances of what makes the CrossFit...
CrossFit Balance shared an image on Facebook

"KIP OR TREAT!" Join Michael Lorenzen this Saturday at 9am for work on your kip! Have an opportunity to break down your mechanics and focus on better efficiency whether applied to pull-ups, toes to bar, or muscle-ups. Perfecting your hollow body swing and doing this well is essential for efficiency. We all can use more work on better activating our hips in the swing! All levels welcome. This will be held in conjunction with the 9am class. Just a reminder we will only be holding a 9am class this Saturday due to the Scavenger Hunt. Everyone who is participating in the hunt....should aim to work with Michael beforehand if you able to "swing" it.

Diablo CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

This is a LONG read. But, if you claim intolerance to gluten, it is a MUST-READ.

Paradigm CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

We are proud to announce that we are now part of Sweat Angels, so each and every Facebook check-in at our location does something good like providing meals for kids or building schools. Get in shape, give back, be a Sweat Angel!

Jason Wilson published the post CrossFit Has the Most Passionate Haters on
  Every time I’m watching a video on YouTube I can’t help but scroll down to read...
LaLanne Fitness shared a link on Facebook

Post your list now! Who from our Community do you recognize on this list?? Which one are you?

CrossFit Milpitas shared an image on Facebook

Jigsaw throwdown going down this saturday. going to have some awesome CFM athletes out there this weekend so if you can get out there and support our CFM teams. Going to be a fun day. Who's going? What's your teams names?

CrossFit Iron Mary's posted on Facebook

I would like to take a minute to brag about the 6 am class and all athletes participating in the Luring Challenge. 2 benchmark workouts in 3 days and EVERYONE hit a PR. Nice job guys and gals. 1 more to go.....

adrummonds published the post Low Carb Bacon-Egg-Cheese Protein Waffle Sandwich! on
Just when you thought it couldn't get any better we have a protein waffle bacon egg and cheese...
CrossFit San Diego posted an article
CrossFit Endurance shared a link on Facebook

Mid Week http://buff.ly/1tgGnSu

CrossFit Endurance posted an article
CrossFit Silicon Valley shared a link on Facebook

Woot Woot Wednesday! - Coach Michaela knows how to have fun. Learning a swinging L-sit rope climb does not have to be all up tight unless we are talking about your core! Hey it's Wednesday! It is time to update you on the coming events this weekend! Friday is Costumed WODs and The Alameda Trunk or Treat starting at 3PM. Saturday is the CrossFit San Jose "FrankenWOD Throwdown". Also this Saturday Nov. 1, starting from 6PM to 2AM, Accendo Real Estate will host a costume ... http://ow.ly/2PPHw0

CrossFit Silicon Valley shared a link on Facebook

http://crossfitsv.com/wod/2014/10/28/wed

liftlaugheatrepeat published the post Beef and Bacon Chunky Pumpkin Chili on Nutrition WOD
Ok guys, I am not going to waste your time with a lot of jabber on this. I just have to come out...
CrossFit Invictus shared a link on Facebook

Attention Invictus Firefighters! Register today for the 2015 Firefighter Throwdown (Jan 27th - 28th) at the San Diego Convention Center. Registration is open until November 15th so don't delay!

LaLanne Fitness posted on Facebook

10.29.14 Yurp!!! It must be done. WOD 2014 CrossFit Games - Triple 3 For time: Row, 3000 m 300 Double Unders Run, 3 mi Everyone will spend 15 minutes max at 3 separate stations. Best time for this WOD at the Games was Rob Forte in 33:03. Good luck!!!

CrossFit Future shared a link on Facebook

“ARCHIE” http://wp.me/s2RAeU-archie

CrossFit Future posted an article
CrossFit Elysium posted on Facebook

10/29/14 WOD- Don't forget about the Halloween Party on 11/1, from 8pm-2am! BYOB and food, but we'll have some beverages and finger food to share! Warmup: CF x 1, burgener for clean strength: clean and jerk, work up to 2 singles at 90% and 2 singles at 95% metcon: AMRAP 6 min- squat clean thruster, 135/95lb

Diablo CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit REALLY is for everyone. Let us show you why http://diablocrossfit.com/about-us/programs/

CrossFit Mission Gorge shared a link on Facebook

Nice job on those Bar Muscle Ups today! Tomorrow: Strict Press for strength, and some running interrupted by a barbell complex for conditioning. Be sure to check our WOD page for upcoming events!

CrossFit Balance shared an image on Facebook

Efficiency tips for tomorrow's workout: Double-unders- Think of this as staying organized. You want to stay connected through your core as in holding enough tension for a rep with as little movement as possible. This means head straight, tight core, legs straight. Arms are by your sides- minimal rotation with elbows/shoulders- all in the wrists, which should be relaxed! Push-ups- The number one thing I see as you are all doing push-ups and getting tired, is the flaring of the elbows. We want to maintain the standard of "elbows in" and "arms internally rotated." Why? This is a more effective pushing position and if you find it more challenging and think it's easier to switch to your elbows out, it's probably because you are compensating with your shoulders and losing that shoulder retraction. Having your elbows in translates to other movements such as the bench press, handstand push-up, and any shoulder to overhead. Soooooooo...as Dan John would say, "execute the simple things extraordinarily well." When you are doing your push-ups back off as opposed to continuing with poor form and break up your sets! Be consistent and hold this as your standard. This also goes for maintaining tension in your core and from the bottom position out of your push-up! If you are seeking gains in strength, this push-up position regarding elbow positioning is very important. Be patient.

LaLanne Fitness shared an image on Facebook

LET'S GO GIANTS!!!!!

GymnasticsWOD shared an image on Facebook

THIS WEEKEND Coach Carl Paoli is coming out to Austin, TX and Goodyear, AZ! He will be teaching at @crossfitcentral on Saturday Nov.1 and Sunday Nov. 2 at #CrossFitFury. For more information and registration, visit: www.gymnasticswod.com/seminars #freestyleconnection

CrossFit Amundson posted an article
GymnasticsWOD shared a link on Facebook

GymnasticsWOD shared a link on Facebook

GymnasticsWOD shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Balance posted on Facebook

Head's up for this weekend- We have had three weekends of Barbell Club on Sunday's.....It's been a great turnout soo far! We will not be holding it this Sunday. We will resume the following week. If the participation continues, we will make this a regular class!

CrossFit Iron Mary's shared an image on Facebook

This is the best time of the day.

Fu Barbell shared an image on Facebook

FuBarbell snapbacks. Christmas is on the horizon. You ready? Drop date: stay tuned. #FuBarbell #ReebokONE #crossfit #crossfitgirls #crossfitmen #Olympicweightlifting #instagramfitness

Fu Barbell posted an article
MobilityWOD shared an image on Facebook

Pathology to Function Part II: Moving beyond "flexibility" | Pro Episode #82 Today's MWod Pro episode is part II in our series about moving from diagnosis to function. If you recall in part 1, we noted that our athlete was missing full range of motion (including stability through rotation) overhead. Today we work backwards and examine her starting position. The MWod template is straight forward, before you go consulting an expert, make sure your athletes have full start, and finish positions. Like starting a dead lift with a rounded back is difficult to correct once under load, so too is reorganizing a compensated shoulder position. When Cawley and Evans originally proposed their 10 general characteristics of fitness, they defined flexibility as "maximizing a range of motion around a given joint". The inherent problem with this definition (they are coaches and invented the Dynamax ball btw..) is that they are not coming from a physiologic position. Rather, they are speaking from a "coaching" perspective, and one that is over ten years old at this point. If we simply value a "one or zero" mindset about positioning and function, then it is easy to see why we continually see the same problems, set backs, and injuries ad infinitum. Maximizing a range of motion around a joint is exactly what athletes do when they compensate for restricted ranges of motion. Missing overhead? No problem, internally rotate your shoulders and buy your self some slack in that capsule and supportive tissue/musculature. Oh, that position is unstable and weak, but you have maximized your range of motion around the shoulder joint. Missing a good front rack shape? No problem, slide your hands so that your shoulders are in terrible position and jack your wrists. Boom, full flexibility. (Just not full Mobility) We have to account for the physiology of the joint (stable and best fit positions) when we assess range of motion and training. I know you can do a bunch of work in a crappy position, until you can't because you are injured. Or until you loose. Or, you can make a better decision. Kstar Go here for the video: http://www.mobilitywod.com/episodes/ (Must be an m|wod pro subscriber)

Molly Eledge published the post Meet the Columnist: Nell Stephenson of Paleoista on
About NELL STEPHENSON Nell Stephenson is the author of Paleoista-Gain Energy, Get Lean and Feel...
CrossFit Invictus shared a link on Facebook

We are dedicating November to "Invictus Around the World"! Starting November 1st through the 30th, post your photos of you in your Invictus shirt and you could win a free Invictus shirt!

CrossFit East Village shared an image on Facebook

Halloween Party Tickets Half Price in advance, only $5! $10 CASH ONLY at the door. What are you waiting for?

CrossFit Brand X Poway posted an article
CrossFit Brand X Poway shared an image on Facebook

Brand X CrossFit Ramona WOD 10:00 EMOM Strict Pull-ups Box Jumps Followed by: 10x 1:00 Row 2:00 rest Mobility: Hips Shoulders Back

MobilityWOD shared an image on Facebook

The definitive pre-thrusters MWOD. http://bit.ly/1tRvIRN

CrossFit Proper shared an image on Facebook

Walk boldly! #crossfitproper #havefundocrossfit #bebetter

Anonymous posted an article
CrossFit No Boundaries shared an image on Facebook

adrummonds published the post Bacon Cups Filled with Chocolate Chip ABS Protein Pancakes! on
Bacon Cups filled with Chocolate Chip Protein Pancakes! This incredible recipe comes from...
CrossFit Fortius shared an image on Facebook

Over the past year, I've had several women ask me if there is an "Upper Body" program, like the Squat programs out there (like the Russian or Miller Squat Programs we use). So I started developing an upper body program about 6 months ago and tested it on Rachelle and Bonnie - with excellent results so far. Rachelle left for Georgia this past week and made these T-Shirts before she left! I still need to make some adjustments before I release it for everyone, but stay tuned! This program helps develop both strength for pull-ups and ring dips, but also for shoulder strength and stability for all things overhead! #teamfortius #crossfit #upperbody #upperbodybyjesse #strength #womanstrength #sandiego #fitfam #instafit #gym #oly #pullups #fitness #sandiegocrossfit #sandiegofitness #livesore #ucsd #sdsu #usd #ymca #weightlifting

CrossFit San Diego posted an article
CrossFit East Village posted an article
CrossFit Future shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit No Boundaries shared a link on Facebook

2014 CrossFit Total Meet http://wp.me/p3sq8Z-3GK

CrossFit No Boundaries posted an article
CrossFit Coronado shared a link on Facebook

Tuesday 28 October

crossfitapogee published the post The 5 Roles of a Coach on
When is a Coach just a Coach? Never. “Coach” is a coverall term used in most every box to...
CrossFit Temecula shared a link on Facebook

Great job logging your workouts on Beyond the Whiteboard everyone! http://www.crossfittemecula.com/2014/10/27/10282014-15min-amrap/

CrossFit Temecula posted an article
CrossFit Mission Gorge shared an image on Facebook

Have you been enjoying the FREE CFMG Yoga Classes every Wednesday at 8pm? Things just got better, because we are now offering TWO Free Yoga Classes for CFMG Members every week! Sunday Yoga at CFMG will begin THIS Sunday, November 2nd at 8am, taught by the lovely Nazli Takesh. We hope to see you there! Please bring your own mat/blocks/straps!

CrossFit Coronado shared an image on Facebook

Erin sporting her new CFC tank in Kandahar Afghanistan. Looking forward to having you back with us soon!

CrossFit Belmont Heights shared an image on Facebook

Before we announce tomorrow's WOD, we want to thank our CFBH family for their love and support as Jess and I tied the knot this last weekend. We were humbled by the love and you don't know the appreciation we had for everyone, when we were able to close the Box for a couple of days, to allow our Coaches, the time to come and celebrate with us as well. We love you guys and we are so happy! Can't wait to see you guys!! Here's tomorrow's WOD... CFBH 10.28 Skills - Hang Snatch, Toes-to-bar WOD a 10 Rounds: :30 "ON" /:30 "OFF" Row for meters *Record lowest meters out of all rounds WOD b 10min EMOM EVEN - 15 Hang Snatches (115/95) ODD - 15 Toes-to-bar

CrossFit Proper posted an article
CrossFit Belmont Heights shared an image on Facebook

WOD 10.27 Results!!

CrossFit Fortius shared a link on Facebook

REMINDER: The 2014 Fortius Halloween Invitational Weightlifting Meet is this Saturday. This is our smallest meet of the year, capped at 50 - and naturally it sold out in one day :) We may have to make it bigger next year! The first session is just-for-fun, costume encouraged. The other 3 sessions will be USAW Sanctioned, with several athletes looking to qualify for the American Open! Come by and watch some weightlifting on Saturday!

@TabataTimes on Twitter

Watch the latest episode of GPTV