CrossFit Open 2014 – What The Hell Was That?

by Richard Bird

Dave Castro tried to kill me. The weapon used? 14.3 with a 14.5 chaser.

Part 1: 14.1 and 14.2

This year’s CrossFit Open was pretty crazy. Not because of the typical burning lungs, screaming quads or shredded hands. Those are everyday concerns in the world of “better today than yesterday”. No, my crazy barometer for this year’s Open was measuring the massive amount of discontent that I heard from CrossFit athletes of every skill, scale and level. From the opening bell of double-unders – literally followed by the statement “really, seriously – double-unders” by just about everyone I know – to the hellaciously nasty 14.5 torture fest (I think I started seeing leprechauns halfway through the set of 15 thrusters) the negative and unhappy commentary I heard at my gym and across the world from other friends in the sport got me to wondering.

Mathematically, how bad was the Open in 2014? More importantly, could the suck be quantified in a way that might give the community pointers on one of many possible explanations? Was it bad programming? Was there an actual effort made to “weed out” a large part of the field right out of the gate? Is CrossFit destined to become Cirque Du Soleil, where only those with ridiculously honed skills stand an iota of a chance of placing in their age, gender, region, etc.? Or, conversely could it be that a very large part of the CrossFit population is just weak? We have to consider all options – even if it means that we might have to admit that we’re not as collectively bad-ass as we think we are. Well, as you think you are – I feel pretty bad ass – in general; if I belt up, and have my Strength Wraps on, have 45 minutes to stretch and then if there aren’t any stupid muscle-ups in the workout. (Yes, I’ve seen the Darnell Sanders video – like 280 times – because it is awesome).

So what does the math say? Actually, a class by class analysis of individual scores was enlightening. I want to make a disclaimer and say that there are no compelling conclusions in these numbers. No smoking gun. But, there is certainly a lot to think about – in particular, I think the figures indicate that CrossFit headquarters might want to be thinking about whether they actually are living up to their marketing related to the “community” aspect of this sport.

First, I had to make personal assumptions about what constituted an “acceptable” performance in each of the Open workouts. These are my assumptions and mine alone. You might completely disagree with them and I can respect that. I actually feel that I set the bar low/conservative for each event (except for 14.5, which was a bear-mother to try to figure out a decent threshold for) and that the assumptions used are supportable. Second, there is definitely the potential for data inaccuracy, but not to a significant enough degree to invalidate the directional results. The reasons for this inaccuracy is that you can’t download the results easily from the Open site. It took me several days to crunch numbers that would have taken 5 minutes with an Excel dump and pivot tables.

Let’s put the “community” aura to the test first. I heard a lot of hype about the number of registered athletes this year many times on the workout broadcasts. 170,000 was a number that kept getting tossed around. Interestingly, the number of recorded scores in 14.1 was actually more than 214,000. The number of posted scores from 14.1 to 14.5 might be a good place to start if we wanted to attempt to measure what “community” looks like. We had 214,000 people pay to get into the Open and we have to assume that they had not only a financial but a personal interest in registering. So if we analyze the trend from 14.1 to 14.5 in terms of how many people actually participated – this could be an indication of the level of community support for the event, the programming and the perceptions of the worldwide body of CrossFit athletes at all levels. How big was the delta over time? Well, I think it is a troubling sign that more than 1 in every 4 athletes didn’t finish the Open.

14-1 Score Trend

If 1 of every 4 registered athletes decided to watch March Madness instead of finishing 14.5, what does that suggest about the “community” and the Open programming?

Something else that jumps off the axis in this set of numbers is the trends related to which workouts inspired athletes to give it a go and which ones clearly had them running for the door (or not running in the door at the gym). The downward trends are certainly suggesting that 14.2, 14.4 and by a huge margin, 14.5 were very unpopular pieces of programming. One striking oddity is that apparently female competitors in the Master’s Women over 60 class were really pumped up about 14.3. You go ladies!

What about each of the individual workouts?

It seems fairly clear that the great gnashing of teeth related to double-unders was actually a lot of whining. Sorry, told you earlier that we need to hold ourselves accountable as well. The assumption for 14.1 is that the mark of reasonable performance was very conservative – that being the completing of the first 30 double-unders. 14.1 was a couplet of 30 double-unders into 15 light power snatches (75, 55, 65, 45). The vast majority of heartburn that I heard about this workout was that the double-under skill was an insurmountable task for many athletes but the number of individuals who did not move in to the snatches was actually very small. With the exception of Master’s Women over the age of 60, anywhere from 9 out of 10 to nearly 10 out of 10 (Individual Men) were able to finish that first set of double-unders.

Not a bad wash-out rate when it comes to double-unders. Wonder if this trend holds for the other 4 workouts in the Open?

Not a bad wash-out rate when it comes to double-unders. Wonder if this trend holds for the other 4 workouts in the Open?


So we came out of the gates like rolling thunder for 14.1! 214,000 athletes with a better than 95% completion rate of the dreaded double-unders. Unfortunately, the party started to get a whole lot less fun in 14.2. The second workout was a time-bonus WOD starting with a 3 minute couplet of Overhead Squats into Chest-to-Bar pull-ups. The performance assumption for this workout is pretty simple; getting into the second 3 minute round was the measure of success. So how many CrossFit athletes made that first cut? Way fewer than I think anyone would have expected – but more importantly, the workout seems to give the first indications of a fundamental programming problem.


Whoa - something went really wrong in 14.2.

Whoa – something went really wrong in 14.2.


The failure rate for 14.2 was nothing short of mind-blowing. Only Individual Males (athletes under 40) came close to a 10% failure rate, moving into at least the second 3 minute round. But the failure rate for all other male athletes up to the first scaled age group (Master’s Men 55 to 59) escalated rapidly to over 20% of all scored athletes. The story for female athletes is really eye-opening though. Not only did every age category of females in the competition clock in at a failure rate ranging between 47% and 68%; female performance was nearly always 4 times worse by category than the same male category. The red lines represent that gap. And lets not mince words on what this means – the confidence interval in the numbers clearly shows that something was consistently and programmatically wrong with this workout. If the progressive increase in failure between each male age group was less than double the next younger group – there is no other explanation for the 400% greater failure rate among female athletes. The female-related scaling was completely wrong and it had an enormous impact beyond percentages. We’re talking individual human beings here, this many:

29,526 Individual Women impacted by the 14.2 programming decision - thinking that might have had an impact on athlete enthusiasm for future workouts.

29,526 Individual Women impacted by the 14.2 programming decision – thinking that might have had an impact on athlete enthusiasm for future workouts.


I’ll dig further into 14.3, 14.4 and the big whopper – 14.5, in my next posting. But I want to leave readers with an important note. This is a mathematical evaluation and not a personal attack. When I use the terms “failure rate” and “washout” it isn’t an grading of any single person’s performance. In fact, 14.1 was a disaster for me personally – it took me three times as long to do my notoriously unlinked double-unders as it did to do the power snatches. I just want to dig a bit beyond the sweat, blisters and dry heaves to determine what we can do better in CrossFit – better today than yesterday, right?

Originally published on on April 8th, 2014.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Printable Version

We Are Scouting Top Writers

Are you passionate about fitness and have something to say? Reach a huge online community and get the discussion going - start writing for Tabata Times today!

Share this post
@TabataTimes on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook 
Advertise Here

Most Popular of All Time

CrossFit Oakland shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Oakland posted on Facebook

Thursday is a Recovery Day.

Morgan Hill CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Week21 day3

Morgan Hill CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Week21 day3

United Barbell shared a link on Facebook

Less than 3 weeks until the "Fight Gone Bad" United for Youth event goes down at United Barbell! Make sure you register to reserve your space!

United Barbell shared a link on Facebook

Survey Results

CrossFit 209 Sport shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Los Gatos posted an article
CrossFitOfFremont posted an article
Kristy Parrish published the post How Do I Choose the Right Workout Program? on Tabata Times
Results outline the efficacy of a workout program. With a sound, objective foundation (i.e...
Berkeley CrossFit posted an article
Berkeley CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit Oakland posted on Facebook

Wednesday's WOD: TIER 1 A. 3 x 3 Snatch Grip Deadlift B. Death by 7 Ball Slams + Burpee TIER 2 A. 3 x 3 Snatch Grip Deadlift B. Death by 5 Wall Balls @ 20#/14# + Double-Unders TIER 3 A. 3 x 3 Snatch Grip Deadlift B. Death by Handstand Push-Ups * Part B has a 15-minute time cap. * For Part B, Tier 1 starts each round with 7 ball slams and increases the number of burpees each round by 1 rep; Tier 2 starts each round with 5 wall balls and increases the number of double-unders by 10 each round (starting at 10 in the first round).

CrossFit Dark Element shared a link on Facebook Who's on top?

CrossFit Dark Element shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Oakdale shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Potrero Hill shared a link on Facebook

WOD- Wednesday, Oct 22 This FRIDAY! Paleo Potluck and Pumpkin Carving! Bring a dish and a pumpkin. 6-9pm No class or open gym this Saturday for the Scream Team competition! Find a partner (guy/guy and gal/gal) to compete with! 3 events, all level …

CrossFit Sweatshop posted an article
CrossFit Potrero Hill posted an article
Corey's Gym posted an article
Morgan Hill CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

week21 day2

Morgan Hill CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

week21 day2

cfsausalito shared an image on Facebook

Congratulations to C/S athletes Galo Arias and Sharon Squire for completing the Warrior Dash over the weekend and to C/S athlete Alicia Asensio for running the Nike Women's Half Marathon on Sunday! We love seeing you all express your fitness in different competitive environments -- so proud of you!

CrossFit Modesto shared an image on Facebook

Happy Tuesday! We'd like to welcome Nestor to our community. You know the drill: if you see him, introduce yourself and say hello. Thanks for joining us, Nestor!

CrossFit Modesto posted on Facebook

ANNOUNCEMENTS -- PLEASE MAKE A NOTE OF THESE IN YOUR CALENDARS! - CrossFit Modesto will be closed ALL DAY October 31st (Halloween) and November 1st for the Hock Hocheim Knife Seminar. - WODTOBERFEST takes place on October 29th at 5:30 PM and will be the *ONLY* class in the pm (NO 12pm or 4:30pm classes)

American River Crossfit shared a link on Facebook


CrossFit Envy posted on Facebook

Prehab/activation: SMR - rhomboids / low back Banded hip flexor stretch 2x10 hip thrusts 2x10 scap retraction on rings -then- 5 x 250m row sprints - rest 2 mins between attempts, post best and worst time -then- AMRAP in 12 minutes: 15 push-presses (75/55) 12 back rack in place walking lunges (75/55) 9 pull-ups

CrossFit Envy posted on Facebook

Competitors Program Week 1, Day 2: 5x5 @ 75-80% weighted ring dip -alternating with- 5 attempts for max time in an L-sit -then- With a 15 minute running clock: Run 1200m* Followed by max rounds of: (1,2,3...) Hang Power Clean (175/120) (1,2,3...) Burpee over the box jump (24"/20") *do the long 800m course, then around the building twice -then- Every 30 seconds for 8 intervals: 1x20yd prowler sprint (176/108) or use a weight that allows you to sprint 20 yards in under 10 seconds. Then, rest 3 minutes and repeat once more.

CrossFit HEALDSBURG posted on Facebook

Competence speaks through confidence and it is easy to carry others along when you believe in yourself. - Mark Twight

CrossFit Bios shared a link on Facebook

South Tahoe CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Ski and Snowboard Conditioning Boot Camp is in full swing! We know who'll be ready for the snow!

CrossFit West Petaluma shared a link on Facebook

Good Ol’ Fashioned Strength Day

South Tahoe CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Avalanche shared an image on Facebook

Check out Derek getting low. Over 50lbs lost and an amazing gain in range of motion!

CrossFit Genesis posted an article
CrossFit Avalanche shared an image on Facebook

The paleo challenge day 1. Can you guess who's paleo bank this is?

Jefferson State CrossFit posted on Facebook

Just watched Julie Noyes complete 3 touch and go power cleans with her previous max! -Stoots

CrossFit Anywhere shared an image on Facebook

Our #MCM goes to Blair and Rob as they prep to crush the competition at Iron October 2 this Saturday! Come out to cheer them, and our other competitors on at CrossFit Iron Mile in Natomas from 9-4!

CrossFit Feather River shared an image on Facebook

This Saturday the 25th is the Yuba Sutter United Way Spooktacular 5k/10k Run! Race starts at 9am and there will be prizes awarded for best costumes! Let's get out there and represent CFFR!!

South Tahoe CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Even though it's only October, we are already thinking about Decking our Halls!!! Mark your calendars!!! STCF Christmas Party is slated for Friday, December 12! You will NOT want to miss this shindig!

CrossFit Valley View posted on Facebook

This week is a special one! Why you ask?! Well because Our Box owner, Jennifer Correia, the one that brought CrossFit to Los Banos, is clebrating her Birthday this Sunday the 26th and guess what 30 burpees are due! so jump on her ass to get them done and hey, why not have her step it up a bit and make it for time????

CrossFit Valley View shared an image on Facebook

Starting off the day right

CrossFit 530 posted on Facebook

CrossFit 530 is closing. Friday will be the last day of business. All billing has stopped and will be refunded on a prorated basis. We sincerely thank everyone for their contribution to our CrossFit community over the last several years and wish you all health and happiness.

mqprunty published the post Why I Compete on
I wasn't quite sure where to go with this article...I first started with – “Why YOU Should...
South Tahoe CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

#crossfit #stcf #mental #southtahoecrossfit #neverquit #mexturesapp

John Mariotti published the post 3 reasons you get hurt at CrossFit on
There is a huge amount of bad press about CrossFit hurting people. I hear about Doctors and...
CrossFit Genesis shared a link on Facebook

October 20, 2014 Workout of the Day #holdthebar #alivetribe #workout #roseville

CrossFit Folsom Lake shared an image on Facebook

Lateral box jumps? Yikes!! Switching it up a little today :-)

Auburn CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

ACF – October 20, 2014

Hilary Wiebe published the post 10 Things I've Picked Up in My First Year of CrossFit on
This past September was my one year CrossFit anniversary. I’m really excited for what lies ahead...
CrossFit Monterey posted on Facebook

Training 141020 Strength: Back Squat 3 @ 7, 3 @ 8, 3 @ 9, plus one down set (load drop) Conditioning – 4 Rounds for time: 400m Run 4 Deadlifts, 115#/75# 4 Power Cleans, 115#/75# 4 Push Press, 115#/75# 4 Front Squats, 115#/75# Post results to comments.

CrossFit Valley View shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Redding posted on Facebook

After meeting with the council we have decided to put the 6am Class on hold. The Mon-Wed-Fri 5a class is still alive and well. 6am'ers gather your peeps and lets get this going again!

arielyve published the post All You Need to Know on Preventing Cancers on
Everyone has cancer cells in their body and these cells never get caught in normal tests until...
CrossFit 38 Degrees North shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit translates to all aspects of life, hopefully it influenced these guys aim over the weekend. Here is four of our 38 North boys on a camo heavy bonding trip into the wild. And the WOD for tomorrow is.......... "The CrossFit Total" 15 Min to find 1RM Back Squats -3 attempts 15 Min to find 1RM Press-3 attempts 15 Min to Find 1RM Deadlift- 3 attempts add highest rep from each movement together to find total

CrossFit Feather River shared a link on Facebook

Workout of the Day for Monday October 20th, 2014

CrossFit CSA posted on Facebook

In teams of two, with only one teammate working at a time, perform the following within 28 minutes: 6 x 100 Meter Row (Each partner rows 100m AND resets it to Zero) 50 Burpee Box Jump Overs (24"/20") 10 Rds of Cindy (5 pull-ups-10pushups-15 squats) 6 x 100 Meter Sprint Run (50m down and back, then partner goes) 10 Rds of Cindy (advanced do Chest to bars) 50 Burpee Box Jump Overs MAX Double Unders Score is number of double unders you complete. It will be very difficult for most teams to even make it to the double unders. *for the run sprints, instructor will set up cones outside 50m apart, where each teammate will run down and then return and tag their partner. ** advanced player please perform chest to bar pull-ups

CrossFit 580 posted on Facebook

Save the date! Saturday November 1, wear your Halloween costumes for the team WOD!

CrossFit Ready shared a link on Facebook

Sam getting one of his 165lb thrusters. #crossfitready #readynation #crossfit #affiliatecup #thrusters

CrossFit Ready shared a link on Facebook

Was that my last Burpee? #crossfitready #readynation #crossfit #burpee #checkwithyourjudge #teamfitaid…

@TabataTimes on Twitter

Watch the latest episode of GPTV