The Ethics of Human Movement

We Are Scouting Top Writers

Are you passionate about fitness and have something to say? Reach a huge online community and get the discussion going - start writing for Tabata Times today!

Print

By Greg Hickey

“There is no reality except in action.” – Jean-Paul Sartre1

Crossfit is constantly varied, high-intensity, functional movement. It consists of physical actions which mimic those performed in everyday life. Clearly, functional movements have considerable value. But how much? Does this value transcend physical benefits and enter the realm of ethics? Loosely defined, ethics consists of the set of precepts governing what an individual person should do.2 People typically conceive of ethics as externally directed; for example, how an individual should treat others or how an individual should act in certain circumstances. Yet under the basic definition, ethics merely comprises the qualities a human being should or should not possess and the actions she should or should not perform. Thus, in addition to not wrongly depriving her fellow humans of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness, a person should be intelligent and fit. By this statement I mean simply that, all things considered, it is better to be more intelligent rather than less intelligent and more physically fit rather than less fit.

In order to be ethical in any respect, humans must act, and action requires movement of one’s body. For any movement, three primary questions arise: 1) how much force must the agent apply?, 2) over what distance must the agent apply that force? and 3) how fast must the agent apply that force? The answers to these three questions define ethical precepts for human movement. They provide the minimum standards for how a human being should be capable of moving.

1. How much force must an agent apply?
Imagine you find yourself in a burning building. Another person lies unconscious on the ground in front of you. Obviously, you should help this person to safety if it is within your power to do so without greatly endangering your own well-being. The question then becomes whether or not you are strong enough to lift and move this lifeless body.

To plead weakness out of ignorance, that you never developed the requisite strength because you never expected to find yourself in such a situation seems at first an acceptable, if unfortunate, response. Yet a perfectly healthy adult’s claim that he never expected to find himself in such a dangerous situation seems little excuse for his cowardice, just as a capable adult claiming she never expected to be without a calculator seems little excuse for her not knowing multiplication tables. While uncontrollable circumstances like age or physical or mental disability might serve as acceptable excuses, ignorance does not.

That said, it does seem unreasonable to presume that a trim 120 pound woman should lift a 400 pound sumo wrestler. Likewise, one should not expect an octogenarian or a pre-adolescent child to complete this task. But a healthy adult between the ages of 20 and 35 is certainly capable of lifting his or her own body weight. These considerations lead us to the following ethical precept for human movement:

Precept 1: A human being should be able to lift an object equal in weight to his or her own body off the ground.
Corollary: A human being should be able to deadlift his or her own body weight.

2. Over what distance must the agent apply a force?3
Much has been said in the Crossfit community about the myriad benefits of squatting. In particular, I am indebted to Dr. Kelly Starrett, DPT, for the concept and basic rationalization of the ten-minute squat test. Here, I build on his explanation to offer a more complete justification of this skill.

According to anthropologist Gordon W. Hewes,

“A quarter of mankind habitually squats in a fashion very similar to the squatting position of the chimpanzee, and the rest of us might squat this way too if we were not trained to use other postures beyond infancy.”4

child squat

Children everywhere are capable of squatting in this position, with parallel feet, heels on the ground and hips below the knees, and there are physiological benefits to practicing this posture.

Humans living in rural, under-developed regions where chairs and Westernized toilets are less prevalent report fewer instances of low back pain (LBP) than do affluent populations and residents of urban areas.5 Thus, generally speaking, LBP is less common in areas where people regularly squat, and more common in urban, developed areas where people regularly sit.

Furthermore, according to studies by Israeli scientist Dr. Berko Sikirov, squatting allows for more complete and unstrained elimination during defecation compared with sitting by promoting greater opening of the junction between the rectum and anal canal. In addition to reducing constipation, Sikirov also demonstrated that squatting helped relieve hemorrhoids, a malady rarely seen in the third world.6, 7

So imagine you are traveling in a part of the world where chairs are scarce. The local people regularly squat when eating meals or using the toilet. Should they be required to provide you with a chair and sit-upon toilet? Or should you adopt their practices? In weighing the merit of the customs of other cultures, one should ask first whether a custom violates any universal ethical norms, and second, whether refusing to follow that custom unfairly burdens or insults its adherents. Given the many benefits of squatting, little reason exists to prefer sitting to squatting from a purely objective standpoint. Furthermore, to demand your hosts provide you with a chair because you are not accustomed to squatting is similar to demanding they feed you the foods you grew up eating instead of their local fare. A traveler must expect to adapt herself to local customs when such customs are not above normal human ability and are no less ethical than the traveler’s own practices. In regards to squatting, this example leads to a second ethical precept for human movement.

Precept 2: A human being should be able enjoy a meal or use the toilet while squatting instead of sitting.
Corollary: A human being should be able to maintain a comfortable resting squat position for at least ten minutes.

3. How fast must an agent apply a force?
Human beings lack many physical advantages held by other animals. We are not particularly big or strong or fast. We do not have sharp claws or teeth or hard shells. Instead, we do possess thick, springy Achilles tendons, relatively strong gluteal and hamstring muscles, the ability to sweat and an upright posture that minimizes our bodies’ exposure to direct sunlight. These attributes allow humans to travel long distances on foot with minimal rest. Our ancestors utilized these traits in persistence hunting, the practice of literally running an animal to death, one still employed by certain populations today. In a persistence hunt, a group of human hunters track their prey on foot with one hunter breaking away from the group to continue the chase each time the animal attempts to rejoin its herd or rest. Most mammals do not sweat as readily as humans and some must stop to pant in order to cool themselves off. As the prey begins to overheat and fatigue, the hunters’ superior thermoregulation systems kick in until they eventually overtake their prey.

Modern persistence hunts observed by anthropologist Louis Liebenberg ranged in duration from three hours fifty minutes to four hours fifty-seven minutes with the hunters averaging a speed of 3.9 to 4.1 miles per hour. To optimize the advantages of the human hunters’ homeostasis, the hunts occurred during the heat of the day, with temperatures ranging from 90° to 108° F.8 To those of us not accustomed to completing a marathon in advance of each big meal, this task is more than daunting. Yet no healthy member of a persistence hunting tribe could reasonably expect to reap the rewards of a hunt without ever participating in the chase himself. Healthy adult humans are capable of covering approximately 20 miles in five hours in temperatures near 100° F. At one time, a human who refused to make herself capable of such an effort warranted the scorn and disapproval of her peers, and even risked starvation.

For comparison’s sake, a pace of 3.9 to 4.1 miles per hour over a modern marathon race distance of 26.2 miles equates to a time of approximately six and a half hours. The optimal temperature for human endurance running is about 55° F, and for every 10° increase above 55°, the average marathon finishing time increases by 1.5% to 3%.9 So in optimal running conditions, a human should be able to cover 26.2 miles in between 5 hours, 44 minutes and 6 hours, 5 minutes.

business runners crop

In the modern world, few humans have a need to cover such distances. But consider that the average American lives about three miles from the nearest hospital.10 Here is a distance one might actually need to travel in an emergency. The men’s and women’s marathon world record times are 2:03:38 and 2:15:25, respectively. The men’s and women’s 5000 meter (3.11 mile) world record times are 12:37 and 14:11, or about 10% of the respective marathon times. So if a human should be able to cover 26.2 miles in six hours, she should also be able to travel on foot to the nearest hospital in 36 minutes.

Precept 3: A human being should (in theory) be capable of persistence hunting on foot for over 20 miles at 4 miles per hour in temperatures around 100° F. A human being should (in actuality) be capable of traveling on foot to the nearest hospital in 30-40 minutes in optimal weather.
Corollary: A human being should (in theory) be able to complete a marathon in optimal weather in six hours. A human being should (in actuality) be able to travel 5000 meters (3.11 miles) in 36 minutes.

While other standards covering the many complexities of force production, range of motion and speed undoubtedly exist, I consider these three precepts fundamental to the ethics of human movement, or the extent to which a healthy adult human should be capable of moving. They provide minimum standards for human movement as measured in these three realms. As such, these guidelines extend beyond a definition of what it means to be physically fit, and serve as ethical standards for all humans. Being an ethical human being requires physical action, and I have attempted to show through examples and argument that a fully ethical human must be capable of these three physical abilities, the ethical precepts for human movement.

______________

  1. Sartre, Jean-Paul. “Existentialism.” Basic Writings of Existentialism, Ed. Gordon Marino, New York: Modern Library, 2004, p. 355.
  2. Aristotle. “The Nature of Virtue.” Ethical Thoery, Ed. Russ Shafer-Landau, Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing, 2007, p. 671
  3. In this section, I address the appropriate range of motion for the human body. Answers to questions of how far an agent should move a physical object or her own body from one geographical location to another are implied in the first and third sections.
  4. Hewes, Gordon W. “World Distribution of Certain Postural Habits.” American Anthropologist, Vol. 57, Iss. 2 (April 1955), p. 231-244. 28 Oct. 2009. Online. 12 July 2013. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1525/aa.1955.57.2.02a00040/abstract.
  5. Volinn, Ernest. “The Epidemiology of Low Back Pain in the Rest of the World: A Review of Surveys in Low- and Middle- Income Countries.” Epidemiology, Vol. 22, Iss. 15 (August 1997), p. 1747-1754. Online. 15 July 2013. http://journals.lww.com/spinejournal/Abstract/1997/08010/The_Epidemiology_ of_Low_Back_Pain_in_the_Rest_of.13.aspx.
  6. Sikirov, Berko A. “Primary Constipation: An Underlying Mechanism.” Medical Hypotheses. Vol. 28, Iss. 2 (Feb. 1989), p. 71-73. 2013. Online. 16 July 2013. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/ pii/0306987789900169.
  7. Sikirov, Berko A. “Management of Hemmerhoids: A New Approach.” Israel Journal of Medical Science, 1987, p. 284-286.
  8. Liebenberg, Louis. “Persistence Hunting by Modern Hunter Gatherers.” Current Anthropology, Vol. 47, No. 6 (Dec. 2006). Online. 12 July 2013. http://www.mattmetzgar.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/08/persistence_hunting.pdf.
  9. Barry, Kristin. “Training in the Heat.” Running Times. 19 July 2011. Online. 14 Aug. 2014. http://www.runnersworld.com/race-training/training-heat.
  10. National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey and National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey. “Distance to Nearest Hospital.” National Center for Health Statistics Research Data Center. Online. 18 July 2013. http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/ahcd/distance_to_nearest_hospital_file.pdf

Greg Hickey is a former Philosophy major, international professional baseball player/coach and fitness coach, and a current forensic scientist, writer and endurance athlete. You can read more of his thoughts on the ethics of human movement on his blog KineSophy.

Printable Version

Looking for a competition near you? Having an event?
Check out our new Event Calendar!

Our event calendar lets you create your own event listing for any type of event - throwdown, adventure race, seminar, you name it. For free. In 2 minutes. It's as easy as writing a Facebook post. And you can embed the calendar right on your website.
Try it today!

Share this post
@TabataTimes on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook 

Most Popular of All Time

Advertise Here
Advertise Here

No Excuses CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

An evolutionary take on Paleo and Low Carb Diets. - http://t.co/KeIoe5pmre

No Excuses CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

What's for dinner? Lose Weight at Dinner With These 9 Paleo Recipes - http://t.co/vvgfhvhKlz

CrossFit S3 posted on Facebook

Friday S3 Conditioning: 5 Rounds: 10 Thrusters (95/65)(75/55)(65/45) 20 Ab Mat Situps 50 Double Unders (Sub=100 Singles + 10 Lateral Bar Hops) 400 M Run

Carolina CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

No Excuses CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Larry Neal http://t.co/SUgxwIvm5Z

No Excuses CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Mario Macrina http://t.co/gELWqGcRno

CrossFit Intense posted on Facebook

Don't forget that our Intense Strongman event is this Saturday at 9 am! We have 36 registrants (which is AWESOME for a strongman event) and we have 7 women signed up! The day will be finished off with the athletes performing a truck pull. This event will be fun for the whole family and is expected to conclude no later than 2 pm. The weather forecast looks great so make plans to attend!

CrossFit Rock Hill posted on Facebook

Hoodie orders will be submitted today at 3pm. If you still want one, post it here!

CrossFit WV shared an image on Facebook

JJ gets a bar muscle on his last day at crossfit wv!!!

CrossFit Rife posted on Facebook

*****reminder there are no 6 or 7pm classes this evening. Please plan accordingly.

CrossFit RVA shared a link on Facebook

WOD 4/10/14 - http://www.crossfitrva.com/2014/04/10/wod-41014/

CrossFit RVA posted an article
CrossFit RVA shared a link on Facebook

RVA Fit 4/10/14 - http://www.crossfitrva.com/2014/04/10/rva-fit-41014/

CrossFit RVA posted an article
cfwhrob published the post 4 Common Kettlebell Swing Errors Made by CrossFitters on Tabata Times
The kettlebell is a common tool in the CrossFit arsenal. Every box has a collection of them, and I...
Patriot CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

CF Teens Spring Break Schedule Mon 4/14- preteens @ 5:30pm, teens @ 6:15pm Weds 4/16- teens @ 6:15pm NO class T/Th! CF Kids class this Sunday 4/13 12pm at Patriot! Hang Snatch 2-2-2-2-2 4 Rounds 10 HSPU 15 Box Jump (24/20) 2 Rope …

North End CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

http://northendcrossfit.com/?p=2118

North End CrossFit posted an article
Ballston CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Compound CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit South Cobb posted an article
No Excuses CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Progenex will be at No Excuses on Saturday! http://t.co/KppjFyEbeI

CrossFit Chesapeake shared an image on Facebook

A great night with the CrossFit Chesapeake Kids!! Rowing, tire drags, and burpees, oh my!!

CrossFit Chesapeake posted an article
CrossFit Rosslyn posted an article
Carolina CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Thursday, April 10th- CCF is always striving to offer our Members MORE than just a "gym membership". Just a reminder of some offers you may not be aware of: - beyond the whiteboard Ever wonder how to keep track of your workouts, times, weights? What about when you're asked to do 80% of a max? CCF offers ALL Members a FREE account with Beyond the Whiteboard. You can track your WOD's, diet, sleep, weight, and so much more from your computer, or mobile device through the BTWB app! Each days WOD is loaded into the system so all you have to do is just enter your time/reps. To sign up, go to www.beyondthewhiteboard.com. YOU WILL NOT NEED TO ENTER ANY CC INFORMATION! If you're having issues signing up, contact Coach Josh here: josh@carolinacrossfit.com - HYLETE Carolina CrossFit is "Powered by HYLETE", and as a part of being "powered by HYLETE", everyone is invited to receive 20% off for LIFE at HYLETE.com. Go to http://hylete.com/poweredbyhyleteathlete to activate your 20% off account. Use promo code "CarolinaCF25" for an additional 25% off your first order, totaling 40% off your first purchase! If having issues getting your account set up, contact Coach Josh here: josh@carolinacrossfit.com - Barbell Club & Intro to Olympic Lifting Want to learn the Olympic Lifts? Ready to transition from Fitness to Balance? Looking to focus on your lifts on a regular basis? For info, and to sign up, contact Coach Joe here: joe.s@carolinacrossfit.com http://barbellsandbabies.blogspot.com/ - MiBek Farms CCF has partnered with Kelsey W. of Mibek Farms to provide our Members with grass fed, grass finished, free ranged beef; raised right down the road in Barnwell, SC. Kelsey will now be here EVERY Monday, alternating between the afternoon and morning classes. For more information on Mibek, check out their website here: www.mibekfarms.com - Exclusive Coaching Your private programming experience will be tailored to your specific needs, and will include: ~Mobility exercises to improve and restore joint range of motion ~Skill-based warm-up to prepare for specific movement patterning ~Strength and conditioning exercises chosen to specifically achieve your goal ~Post-workout recovery techniques ~Health, wellness, and lifestyle support Private programming is recommended if you have been sedentary for a long period of time, are training for a specific sport or event, have significant health limitations, or just prefer the additional attention and accountability. Exclusive programming can be done online or at Carolina CrossFit. For additional EC information, contact Coach Joey here: joey@carolinacrossfit.com - Palmetto Sports Massage CCF has an onsite Sports Massage Therapist in Shaun Phillips. When he's not at CCF, you can catch him on the sideline of the USC Football games and various other Gamecock Athletics programs. For more information, or to set up an appointment, contact Shaun here: palmettosportsmassage@gmail.com www.palmettosportsmassage.com - Vaughn Physical Therapy, LLC CCF also has an onsite Physical Therapist. Dr. Brandon Vaughn, DPT, Cert. SMT, Cert. DN American Physical Association Member For more information, or to set up an appointment, contact Brandon here: brandon@vaughnpt.com www.vaughnpt.com ___________________ Open Gym 10am-6pm Optional WOD- Fitness & Balance: Z1 (easy pace- non stop) 1 min AD 1 min row 1 min bear crawl 1 min jump rope singles 1 min FLR 1 min run x 5

Brickhouse CrossFit posted on Facebook

Don't forget about Yobility at 6am tomorrow morning with a Coach Alicia!

CrossFit Old Town shared a link on Facebook

Patriot CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Everyone is invited to join PCFer ML Gilbride's family and friends in a celebration of her life and legacy by participating in a CrossFit WOD in her honor. All are welcome to participate, spectate, or just come out to honor our friend. Registration link and details below. http://www.active.com/event_detail.cfm?event_id=2128714

CrossFit WV shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Rock Hill posted on Facebook

Sorry for the inadvertent omission of a few members of our family in previous post. Also wanted to give a big shout out to Malia Cooke Storino and Rita Revels. Both of these ladies also ran the Cooper River Bridge run this past weekend. Great job Ladies!

CrossFit Falls Church shared an image on Facebook

Strong work today

CrossFit Woodbridge posted an article
CrossFit Woodbridge posted an article
CrossFit Rosslyn shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit Iconz shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Fairfax shared a link on Facebook

5 rounds for time: • 5 Pistols Right leg • 5 Pistols Left leg • 5 Deadlifts 275#/185# • 10 T2B

CrossFit Reston shared a link on Facebook

5 rounds for time: • 5 Pistols Right leg • 5 Pistols Left leg • 5 Deadlifts 275#/185# • 10 T2B

No Excuses CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Thursday 4.10.14 http://t.co/lFPjdgEpYh

CrossFit Arlington posted an article
Patriot CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit West Springfield posted an article
No Excuses CrossFit posted an article
No Excuses CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

What's the best TV theme song? 25 Iconic TV Theme Songs - http://t.co/EUmz7srU0Z

CrossFit Intense shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit Intense shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit Iconz posted on Facebook

: ICONZ New Post : Thursday WOD April 10 - http://crossfiticonz.com/workout-of-the-day/thursday-wod-april-10/

CrossFit Iconz posted an article
shortz published the post Is it time to pay judges? on
Is it time to pay judges? CrossFit and CrossFit Competition is big business. There is a lot of...
CrossFit South Cobb shared an image on Facebook

Don't forget…. DogWOD May3. Mark your calendars. $15 to workout + silent auction--all proceeds benefit LifeLine Animal Project! See you there 9am-1pm!

CrossFit Intense posted on Facebook

Thursday's WOD Press 5 x 65% 5 x 75% 5 x 85% 5 Rounds For Time: Walking barbell lunge x 20 @ 75% Bodyweight 3 stones to shoulder @ 75% Bodyweight

CrossFit Chronic posted an article
CrossFit Rubicon posted an article
CrossFit Falls Church shared an image on Facebook

Max and Texas working hard this afternoon...

CrossFit Intense posted on Facebook

We are just a little over one week away before our YOGA class starts! Every Saturday morning, beginning April 19th, at 8 am, come join Tonya Madia as she helps you recover from the rigors of your weekly CrossFit workouts and assists you in increasing your mobility.

Ballston CrossFit posted on Facebook

New website is live!! Featuring many of our members. What do you think?

Brickhouse CrossFit posted on Facebook

Congratulations to Brickhouse athlete Sean O'Brien and his wife Angela on the arrival of their healthy baby boy William Cooper O'Brien!

Brickhouse CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Coach Neal Jamison says an "aerobic finisher" does the body good. What exactly is he talking about?

CrossFit West Springfield posted an article
CrossFit Rock Hill shared an image on Facebook

Athletes: we know you have friends that don't do CrossFit YET - so invite them to give it a try! Back by popular demand..... BRING-A-FRIEND SATURDAY is this Saturday, April 12th at 9 a.m.!

@TabataTimes on Twitter

Watch the latest episode of GPTV