Frustration: A Tale of the “Good” Doctor

Love to Eat? Introducing

Are you passionate about food, nutrition and recipes? Unleash your inner foodie and check out our brand-new site - share your favorite recipes at Nutrition-WOD today!

Print
by PAUL KLEIN, Co-owner of CrossFit 77

Allow me to start with an edited scene from the hit movie Pulp Fiction:

Vincent: I got a threshold, Jules. I got a threshold for the abuse that I will take. Now, right now, I’m a racecar, right, and you got me the red. And I’m just sayin’, I’m just sayin’ that it’s dangerous to have a racecar in the red. That’s all. I could blow.

Jules: Oh! Oh! You ready to blow?

Vincent: Yeah, I’m ready to blow.

Jules: Well, I’m a mushroom-cloud-layin’ mother******, mother******! Every time my fingers touch brain, I’m Superfly T.N.T.; I’m the Guns of the Navarone!

That is me right now, I feel like Superfly T.N.T., the Guns of the Navarone, a racecar in the red, ready to blow. For the first time, I had to part ways with a personal programming client. The reason is so appalling that I need some time to vent my frustration.

Evaluating the Client

Evaluating the Client

What this guy needed was a diet that will help control his hunger, stimulate his metabolism and at the same time help balance his hormone deficiency. For workouts, he needs to lift heavy weight and walk.
I will spare all the details, but it starts with a male weight loss client. In his initial evaluation, he weighed over 300#; the fat caliper score was alarming with his pec site being more than double the tricep site (an indication of low testosterone); and his tape measurements at the waist and hips were both over 50″. What this guy needed was a diet that will help control his hunger, stimulate his metabolism and at the same time help balance his hormone deficiency. For workouts, he needs to lift heavy weight and walk. That is it. The goal should be to build muscle, which will help increase his testosterone levels and increase his metabolic rate. He doesn’t need to run, jump, or anything with intensity. And he especially doesn’t need to be on an extreme starvation diet with zero fat. His body is already stressed. Why add to that stress?

Enter the family physician. After a check up with his family doctor, blood work revealed just what we had suspected: he is pre-diabetic and has low testosterone. Here is where my anger starts. The doctor decides that the best thing for this guy is to be on an extremely low-calorie, zero-fat diet. And by “low-calorie” I mean 500 calories per day. Think about that!: 500 calories a day for a 300-pound male with low testosterone. When I asked about how hungry he would get, he said it wouldn’t be a problem because the “good” doctor also prescribed an appetite suppressant.

A Prescription for Failure

Along with 500 calories, this starvation diet also has a whopping zero grams of fat, despite the fact that studies have shown low fat diets lower testosterone.

I told this client that if he chose to follow this protocol, I wouldn’t be able to sleep at night if I programmed workouts for him.

500 calories a day, with a macronutrient breakdown of:

  • 50g of protein,
  • 0 grams of fat
  • 50 grams of carbs.

This isn’t enough fuel for him to get an erection! Much less build muscle.

I wouldn’t even be comfortable asking this guy to walk around the block. I promptly told him that he needed to FIRE his doctor and find one who wasn’t completely ignorant to nutrition and its affects to the body. When I voiced my concerns, he informed me that he respected my opinion but that he was going to listen to his doctor.

So we parted ways.

What angers me the most is that this guy ISN’T being put on a path to success. A 500-calorie diet with appetite suppressants is a recipe for failure. In more ways than one. My prediction for him is as follows:

The list could go on and on. Before long, this poor guy is on a list of prescriptions that need a little daily pill organizer box. And this is all assuming that the Dr. hasn’t put this guy on a statin, which could send him down a rabbit hole of side effects that may be impossible to recover from. Does a doctor like this ever consider these scenarios? We can even forget the list of pills for a second. How do you transition a guy from a 500-calorie a day diet back to a normal life? It is a doomed scenario for this guy: he will most likely go from this starvation plan right back to a diet of chips, diet soda, and Jiffy peanut butter. Only this time, he will have no muscle mass to help with the metabolism. Which will make gaining back the fat a very likely situation.

Nice job leading your patient to success, Doctor!

Does Doctor Really Know Best?

Does Doctor Really Know Best?
Here at 77, we work our tails off promoting lifestyle changes as the answer to long-term health and fitness. We live what we preach. This may make us sound conceited, but it’s the truth and it shows.

Looking for an answer: Despite all our success with clients, we will always be trumped by the recommendations of a doctor. Even if it is a ludicrous as a 500-calorie a day diet with appetite suppressants.
I never ask a client to do something that I don’t or haven’t done myself.

I can only wonder what this doctor looks like. Is he practicing what he preaches? Is the “good” doctor sub 15% body fat with stellar blood work? Or is he reflection of his clients?

I would love to know how many lasting weight loss success stories he has versus how many yo-yo dieters he has created. The odds are good that all he can show is a list of patients who are a tax on the health care system because he never took the time to show them a correct and healthy path to success.

Despite all our success with clients, we will always be trumped by the recommendations of a doctor. Even if it is a ludicrous as a 500-calorie a day diet with appetite suppressants. So what do we do? We have an army of people that we feel 100% confident in referring clients to for help. Want a good massage? We have two of the best in the business. Need a chiropractor that does the best soft tissue work in the area? We will give you his card. Got a baby on the way? We have an ob/gyn who won’t steer you wrong. But if you need a family doctor…damn it. I have nothing for you.

How bad is it? I have been referring people to a place in Reno, Nevada that I trust will give sound advice. Think about how crazy that is — there are family doctors on every corner here in North Carolina, and I would rather send someone to do a Skype call with a doctor on the other side of the country. What is the answer? More patient education? More nutrition education for doctors? Less pharmaceutical sales influence in the doctors’ offices? Or maybe, someone reading this knows of a family doctor who is not just a pill pusher and will email us his contact information? God, I hope that is the case, because I am out of ideas and I am running in the red. And we all know what results from running in the red.

Paul Klein is the co-owner/head trainer at CrossFit 77 in Mooresville, NC. 

Printable Version

We Are Scouting Top Writers

Are you passionate about fitness and have something to say? Reach a huge online community and get the discussion going - start writing for Tabata Times today!

Share this post
@TabataTimes on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook 

Contribute to this story by commenting below:

Advertise Here

Most Popular of All Time

CrossFit 101 shared a link on Facebook

http://crossfit101.com/waiting-exhale/

CrossFit Los Gatos posted an article
Berkeley CrossFit posted an article
mindcoach published the post Confidence and High Intensity Performance on Tabata Times
I know we just moved out of ski season, but skiing has so much to teach us about mental strength...
Morgan Hill CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

week5 wod4 http://wp.me/p3Bc8L-jj

CrossFitOfFremont posted an article
Berkeley CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit 101 posted an article
CrossFit Potrero Hill shared a link on Facebook

WOD- Thursday, July 3 SKILL OF THE MONTH: MUSCLE-UP Weekly Homework: do this before class, after class, or at open gym to improve your muscle ups! Week 7/1-7/6/14 1. Swing Hip to Rings 3×8 2. Ring Supports 3×8 3. Ring Rows 3×10 4. False Grip Hang 2x …

CrossFit Oakland posted on Facebook

Thursday is a Recovery Day!

Max Fitness CrossFit posted on Facebook

7/3/14 Come in, work on a skill! Make up a WOD.

CrossFit Dark Element shared a link on Facebook

http://cfdarkelement.com/whiteboard/

CrossFit Dark Element shared a link on Facebook

http://cfdarkelement.com/daily-wod/

CrossFit Sweatshop posted an article
San Carlos CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Oakdale shared a link on Facebook

http://cfoakdale.com/2014/07/03/kevins-climb-completed/

San Carlos CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Lots of snatches tomorrow #crossfit #snatch #fit #fitness #exercise #lift #wod #pr #crossfitgirls @mjett74

San Carlos CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Working on our base. #crossfit #rowing #fit #fitness #wod #lift #exercise @mmaclean01

Concord CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Welcome some new faces :-) great job tonight Courtney, John and Megan!!!

CrossFit Potrero Hill posted an article
CrossFit Mill Valley shared an image on Facebook

Worlds colliding to save lives. Juggling for Jude #poweredbymammoth

CrossFit 209 Sport shared a link on Facebook

https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=735577119822185&id=163071317072771

CrossFit 209 Sport posted on Facebook

What will you be making for your 4th of July BBQ??? Let's hear it!! https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=410308475776149&substory_index=0&id=271313329675665

CrossFit 209 Sport shared an image on Facebook

https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=284606848385040&id=148284738683919 More info on knee pain!!

CrossFit 101 shared a link on Facebook

Scamper Pics are up!

saulj shared a link on Facebook

Not saying anything, just saying...

San Carlos CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Back in action #thrusters #crossfit #fit #fitness #exercise #lift #wod

CrossFit Oakdale posted on Facebook

http://www.playbuzz.com/erikw/what-crossfit-exercise-are-you

CrossFit Cypher shared an image on Facebook

It's the new planking? AM crew helds it down!

CrossFit Cypher shared an image on Facebook

It's the new planking? AM crew helds it down!

CrossFit Cypher shared an image on Facebook

It's the new planking? AM crew helds it down!

CrossFit Cypher shared an image on Facebook

It's the new planking? AM crew helds it down!

CrossFit Cypher shared an image on Facebook

It's the new planking? AM crew helds it down!

CrossFit Los Gatos shared an image on Facebook

Noon class finishing strong today! Kb's, push jerks and C2b pull ups! Oh ya ;)

CrossFit Envy shared a link on Facebook

Oops, forgot to mention, use the link to sign up and help a brother out :-P.

CrossFit Envy shared a link on Facebook

Hey everyone! Inov-8's, along with Skins and CEP compression gear, and other great gear for CrossFit.

CrossFit Modesto posted on Facebook

Just a little FYI guys, Friday July 4th. Coach Chris will be in at 5:30am for a workout and Coach Billy will be in at 9am as well! These are the only two classes for Friday, so prepare for some fun!

CrossFit Davis shared a link on Facebook

Make Coach Elliot happy and sign up for the Tommy Kono Meet coming up in August! There are sign up sheets at the gym! Talk to Elliot or any other coach for more info!

Tamalpais CrossFit posted on Facebook

July Happenings: Friday July 4th- 8 & 9am Classes only! Sunday July 6th- 9am Swim WOD at COM Kentfield Pool Sunday July 6th- Oly Strong moves to 10:15am on Sundays Tuesday July 8th- 11-11:45am CrossFit Kids starts, 2 spots left, register today! Parents WOD while your kid plays! Saturday July 12th- Crosstown Throwdown TCF vs Santa Rosa Strength and Conditioning – 11:45-2 pm at TCF, sign up on competition board located in SRB- all levels welcome! July 21st- Clarke Holland attends and dominates the CrossFit Games 2014

FTF Fitness posted an article
CrossFit Petaluma posted on Facebook

Schedule for the week of July 4th: Friday, July 4th: 10am class @ CSC only Saturday, July 5th: 10am class @ CSC only Make your way up to CrossFit Sonoma County to pick a Hero workout to complete in honor of Independence Day! The gym will be open from 10am-11:30am. Come in and throw down before a day filled with food, family, and fireworks!

Berkeley CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit 209 Sport posted on Facebook

4th of July hours 8 and 9 AM only!!

bevchildress published the post Do You Struggle With Chronic Disease? on
I live with Rheumatoid Arthritis Disease. I’ve done a pretty good job of keeping it at bay and...
mlsweezey published the post Baby Got Back: My New CrossFit Ass and Other Image Crushing Muscles on
Random Person: “um, do you workout?” Me: “No. This totally happens by accident. Strangest...
Morgan Hill CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

My awesome 7pm Metcon class workin' hard!

United Barbell shared an image on Facebook

Recognize any of these shoes?? You've got 1 day to message me (Jenny) or come and claim them or they will be donated to the needy UB Oly Shoe-less.

United Barbell shared a link on Facebook

Dare to be Great

CrossFit Modesto shared an image on Facebook

Last nights Pull Up Skill,Clinic was full as can be! We had people get their first Kipping Pull Up, we had others improve their technique, and started others on their way to getting pullups! It was great time yesterday, good work to all those who attended!

CrossFit HEALDSBURG posted on Facebook

Schedule for 4th of July weekend Thursday, July 3rd 6:00am 8:30am 9:30am 12:00pm 5:00pm Friday, July 4th 8:30am 9:30am 12:00pm Saturday, July 5th 9:00am Have a safe and happy 4th!!

South Sacramento CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

24:17 top time for the ladies for Shakira!

South Sacramento CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Mr. Sub 20 Michael! 19:40 score to beat.

American River Crossfit shared a link on Facebook

07/02/2014 http://wp.me/sGeX1-07022014

CrossFit East Sacramento shared a link on Facebook

Today's blog post is up on the CFES Blog - [4th of July Outta The Box WOD @ Guy West]

CrossFit Envy posted on Facebook

Prehab/activation: SMR - low back / erectors 2 min Banded hamstring mobilization 2x10 glute bridges 2x10 supermans -then- 10x2 Banded Speed deadlifts Take a few minutes to find a reasonable work weight for Banded deadlifts. It will be in the 50-70% range of your best Deadlift... But use a weight that allows you to PULL FAST off the floor, and lockout fast, even with the band. Hold each lockout for a 3 count, and deload the bar between reps. Guys use the blue or red band, and girls use red. -then- 4 rounds for time: 400m run 500m row 60 double unders

CrossFit Envy posted on Facebook

Competitors Program Week 6, Day 3: 6x3 Power Cleans from the blocks @ 70-75% (at the knee or slightly above) -then- AMRAP in 10 minutes: (4,8,12...) toes to bar *unbroken 25' handstand walk after each round *if you complete the round of 24, then stop and mark the time -then- 4 rounds for time: 400m run 500m row 60 double unders

mindcoach published the post The Importance of Performance Goals on
I’ve written several posts and articles on the mental strength skill of goal setting, so this...
CrossFit West Petaluma shared a link on Facebook

Red, White, and Blue! http://blog.genesispetaluma.com/?p=2664

CrossFit Folsom Lake shared a link on Facebook

It's a new month! What are you going to do with it? These folks are making it happen! http://t.co/AJV8iYk8OR

CrossFit Davis shared an image on Facebook

June! Another great month at CFD!

@TabataTimes on Twitter

Watch the latest episode of GPTV