Low Bar vs. High Bar Back Squat

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (1 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)
Page:  1 Next »
Print


We can all agree that having good squat fundamentals and building strength through back squatting is crucial, whether CrossFit is your primary sport or not. If you are an athlete, you better be squatting.

That being said, not everyone agrees about the low bar back squat vs. the high bar back squat. There are — not surprisingly — advantages and disadvantages to both, and some athletes train both movements. For the same reasons that it is important to understand the difference between American and Russian kettle bell swings, or strict vs. kipping pull-ups, so too should you have knowledge of both kinds of back squats so you can train according to your needs.

Here we bring you two thoughtful perspectives from athletes who have trained both the low bar and high bar back squat and discuss the efficacy of each style.

Low Bar vs. High Bar: The Difference in Muscular Recruitment

Justin Lascek of 70′s big describes the differences in muscular recruitment between the low bar and high bar back squat, the former placing higher demands on the hamstrings and posterior chain.

The high bar squat: the descent occurs, the knees flex acutely at the bottom in the hole, the ascent begins with zero hamstring tension due to knee flexion, as the knee angle opens the hamstrings can receive tension, and there is hamstring tension during the ascent.
The positioning of the bar will dictate what mechanics must be used to maintain lifting efficiency. The mechanics will dictate what musculature is used. Succinctly, more vertical squat techniques use the quads and glutes as the primary movers while the low bar puts a premium on the posterior chain (particularly the hamstrings) for hip drive. The low bar squat also has a balanced anterior/posterior force at the knee because the focus on the hamstring contraction pulls back on the knee. In contrast, the high bar has more of an anterior stress since the quads are the primary movers and attach at the front of the knee at the patella. There is some quadricep involvement in the low bar squat, but not nearly as much as the high bar squat. There is a little hamstring involvement in the high bar, but not nearly as much as the low bar squat.

The forward knee placement in the front and high bar squats result in an acute knee angle. An acute knee angle means that the hamstrings — crossing the knee and hip joints — are contracted and slackened. If the hamstrings are fully contracted, then they cannot contract to help extend the hip out of the hole. This means that in vertical squatting styles, there is no hamstring involvement out of the hole, and limited involvement throughout the ascent. However, note the slight torso difference between the front and high bar squats; the inclination in the high bar style provides more of an angle that allows some hamstring tension. The upper two-thirds of the ascent of a high bar squat can have assistance by the hamstrings to hold the back angle in place (the same way that they do with the low bar or a deadlift). This makes sense as the position can re-apply tension on the hamstrings once the knees are no longer acutely flexed. I have felt this when high bar squatting, but you can see it during these hellacious sets that Max Aita did at California Strength.

The low bar squat maintains tension throughout the descent, creates a stretch reflex to “bounce” off the tense hamstrings, and then utilizes the hamstrings to extend the hip. During the ascent, the quads obviously extend the knee, but they help create balance around the knee so that the hip drive doesn’t tip the torso forward.
To clarify the hamstring involvement during the high bar: the descent occurs, the knees flex acutely at the bottom in the hole, the ascent begins with zero hamstring tension due to knee flexion, as the knee angle opens the hamstrings can receive tension, and there is hamstring tension during the ascent. Note that this tension is not a primary mover due to the torso angle.

In contrast, the low bar squat maintains tension throughout the descent, creates a stretch reflex to “bounce” off the tense hamstrings, and then utilizes the hamstrings to extend the hip. During the ascent, the quads obviously extend the knee, but they help create balance around the knee so that the hip drive doesn’t tip the torso forward (the torso obviously needs to maintain it’s angle out of the hole). Since this style of squatting is dependent on the hamstrings, the body’s positioning — particularly the knees — is much more important. If the knees shift forward at the bottom, then hamstring tension will decrease and will result in no bounce whatsoever. Discussing other faults in the low bar squat leaves the scope of this post.

Page 1 2 3 Next »
Printable Version

We Are Scouting Top Writers

Are you passionate about fitness and have something to say? Reach a huge online community and get the discussion going - start writing for Tabata Times today!

Share this post
@TabataTimes on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook 

Contribute to this story by commenting below:

Advertise Here

Most Popular of All Time

CrossFit Wilmington posted an article
CrossFit Wilmington shared an image on Facebook

John S. - member since 2011 - has been putting in the time and hard work. Keep your eyes on him for a strong push in the 2015 Masters Competition.

CrossFit Wake Forest posted on Facebook

9/29/2014 WOD: Find your Split Jerk 1 Rep Max. Then: CrossFit Games Open 13.4 As many reps in 7 mins as you can of: 3 Clean & Jerks, 135/95 lbs 3 Toes To Bars 6 Clean & Jerks, 135/95 lbs 6 Toes To Bars 9 Clean & Jerks, 135/95 lbs 9 Toes To Bars 12 Clean & Jerks, 135/95 lbs 12 Toes To Bars 15 Clean & Jerks, 135/95 lbs 15 Toes To Bars 18 Clean & Jerks, 135/95 lbs 18 Toes To Bars If you complete the round of 18, go on to 21. If you complete 21, go on to 24, etc. This workout begins from the standing position with the barbell on the floor and the Athlete standing tall. Every rep counts in this workout.

mindcoach published the post Achieving Flow Through CrossFit on Tabata Times
Have you ever heard someone declare that they were “in the zone” or “going with the flow?”...
Paradiso CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit Indian Trail shared an image on Facebook

Another candid picture from yesterday!

Raleigh CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit Wilmington shared a link on Facebook

Wow. http://olympictalk.nbcsports.com/2014/09/28/dennis-kimetto-berlin-marathon-world-record/

CrossFit Indian Trail posted on Facebook

Good luck today, Nate!! (LKM)

CrossFit RDU shared an image on Facebook

Our RDU athletes on the podium at the 2014 Strongman Comp. Great job ladies, we are proud. #crossfit #crossfitrdu #strongman #strongwoman #podium #ncstrongman

CrossFit Indian Trail shared an image on Facebook

Alex getting ready!

CrossFit Exchange shared an image on Facebook

Congrats to Phil and his bride Nikki!!

CrossFit Harrisburg shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit RTP posted an article
Ultimate CrossFit posted an article
Ultimate CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit Indian Trail posted on Facebook

Alex hit two competition PRs today. Snatch at 102kg. Clean and jerk at 135kg. This is 27kg higher than his last competition. Great job!! (LKM)

CrossFit 919 posted on Facebook

Doors will open Sunday morning at 10 am for the IntraGym Challenge. We will plan to start at 11 am or shortly thereafter. There is no Open Gym.

21 CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Here's a great local cause you can support next Saturday in downtown Durham at 8am. Free Chick-fil-A afterwards! http://cfaraceseries.com/races/127/

CrossFit Harrisburg posted on Facebook

CFH is doing great at Disney!! Sunny is currently 45th of 113, Charlotte is 6th of 12 (2 CF games athletes in Charlottes division!!) and Sean is 2nd in his age division! Gooooo CrossFit Harrisburg!

CrossFit Durham shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Durham posted an article
CrossFit 77 posted on Facebook

Retweeted 77 Elite Performance (@77EliteSpeed): I want everyone to know how much I appreciate @CrossFit_77 @kloo_amanda and all the parents that participated in #LetsMove class!! #BeELITE

CrossFit Indian Trail posted on Facebook

Great day so far. Katie Debbie and Hanna represented very well!!! Paul and Lauren got 4th place. Alex lifts tonight at 5 and I lift tomorrow at 9. If you can't make it you can stream it live on. MuscleDriver's YouTube page!!!!

CrossFit Indian Trail shared an image on Facebook

Way to go Paul and Lauren!! (LKM)

CrossFit Indian Trail shared an image on Facebook

Great job this morning, Ladies!!

South Charlotte CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

Awesome effort today at the Beast Mode competition, SCCF and CFD atop the podium. Big thanks again to Brandon for stepping in for J and his strained titty!

CrossFit Durham shared an image on Facebook

Paradiso CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit BWI shared an image on Facebook

Mats are here! We're ready for the Gymnastics Workshop today!

CrossFit Eternal shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit BWI posted on Facebook

Good luck to all 12L athletes competing this weekend!

CrossFit Harbor East posted on Facebook

Saturday, September 27, 2014 CrossFit WOD: 50-40-30-20-10 Box Jumps (24/20) Burpees Scaled - step ups Competitor Part A - 20 fs @ bw. from the floor. Goal is sub 1 min Part B - For time: 500m row 20 thrusters 95/65# 20 burpees to plate 10 muscle ups Part C - Weighted pull ups. 3x2 heavy Part D - Every 90 sec: 3 tng heavy DL 6 burpees over bar 15 ub dbls For 7 sets (00, 1:30, 3, 4:30, 6, 7:30, 9 min marks)

CrossFit Eternal shared a link on Facebook

Good luck to our athletes competing in the Beast Mode Battle today- Sammi, Chris, KO, Liz, Kat, and Emma.

CrossFit Dilworth posted on Facebook

CFE 9.27.14: 4RFT: 800M Run 30 Burpees 30 Abmat sit-ups

CrossFit Silver Spring posted an article
CrossFit Silver Spring posted an article
CrossFit DC shared an image on Facebook

Smackdown workouts are posted: http://crossfitdc.com/?p=7173

CrossFit Eternal posted on Facebook

M O B I L I Z E Your bad self. Saturday. 10am. You work hard, you deserve it.

CrossFit WhiteMarsh posted an article
CrossFit MPH shared a link on Facebook

Saturday, September 27, 2014 http://wp.me/piA1g-7Ek

CrossFit Eternal posted an article
CrossFit Federal Hill posted an article
CrossFit Brave shared a link on Facebook

South Baltimore CrossFit posted on Facebook

Come out and support the 2 teams and 2 individuals competing in the Charm City Throwdown tomorrow! It will be at Outsiders CrossFit tomorrow starting at 8am and running all day. Everyone has been prepping hard and now it's time to see what we're made of. Should be a blast!

CrossFit Praxis shared an image on Facebook

Tomorrow we will be filling in one these empty spaces...

CrossFit WhiteMarsh posted on Facebook

Hey nooners, thanks for tolerating my double caffeinated self! I know I was a handful ! :) Great job everyone and welcome to AA Chris R.!!!

JohannUnderdogTraining published the post A Few of Your Favorite Trainer's Annoying Catchphrases on
You've heard them all before during your sessions with your trainers. And, by now you might be well...
CrossFit DC shared an image on Facebook

(final) Haiku to a Smackdown Workout Announcement!! --- Patience exhausted! so, at last, workouts announced. Is it possible? --- - Workout #1 (whole team): "Rowpes" - Workout #2: (1 guy & 1 girl): "Bearied in the Sand" - Workout #3: (1 guy & 1 girl): "Fed-Up" - Workout #4: (whole team): "Disthrustable" -

Arenal Fitness posted an article
Arenal Fitness shared an image on Facebook

IT'S TONIGHT!!! DON'T MISS IT!!! EVERYONE IS WELCOME!!! Food Truck Rally CrossFit Giveaway! 4-pack of CrossFit Introductory Classes FREE Tell one of our Coaches at the Rally what the acronym WOD means to win! For new members only. Complete all 4 Intro classes and get a chance to win even more! Contact Lauren & Donna, owners@arenalfitness.com, for more details.

CrossFit MPH shared a link on Facebook

Our free beginners' workout goes down at 12p tomorrow! No experience necessary--come on by for a workout! We look forward to meeting you! http://ow.ly/BKa83

CrossFit BWI shared an image on Facebook

We've still got spaces available in Saturdays Gymnastics Workshop from 12-2pm at Columbia District. Contact social@the12labours.com to reserve your spot! Who's excited to work on gymnastics this weekend? #12labours

CrossFit DC shared an image on Facebook

Haiku to a Final Smackdown Hint --- clean, clear and up front? maybe straight forward? such hints cannot be thrusted!

CrossFit Balance shared a link on Facebook

For those of you interested in competing in Miami this January...Check out workout details and qualification process below. First 2 workouts were posted this week and you would have until Monday to submit. Chris Clyde and Danielle will be participating in the online qualifier. Also, in the spirit of the workouts we will be programming the qualifiers first workout this Monday! Check out details below. Otherwise, we will be programming some of these over the next couple weeks for classes! https://www.thewodapalooza.com/

savfmarie published the post Box Talk: Burpees and Breathing on
I see a lot of common, albeit unfortunate, reactions when people start to do burpees. The one I...
zmosbarger published the post Blown Away in Canton on
Only at Reebok CrossFit One would it be possible to be partnered up during class with a Reebok...
LaLanne Fitness shared an image on Facebook

Join us today as we celebrate what would have been Jack LaLanne's 100th birthday!!!

Kristy Parrish published the post Why I Quit CrossFit to Run the Akron Marathon on
Let me be clear from the beginning: I am not quitting CrossFit forever to become a runner. It is...
CrossFit Endurance shared a link on Facebook

Long Interval http://buff.ly/1ytDl2G

@TabataTimes on Twitter

Watch the latest episode of GPTV