The Kipping Pull-Up: Debate and Application

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Page:  1 Next »
Print
by MISSY ALBRECHT, DPT, CSCS, FMS| Physical Therapist/Coach

The Kipping Pull-Up: Debate and Application

When is the correct time to start kipping pull-ups? Is there a recommended number of strict pull-ups an athlete should have before they kip? Are these rules actually enforced and do they need to be?
The PT’s opinion: I err on the side of caution and try to recommend 5 strict pull-ups before kipping with every athlete I encounter, which was a common response from most of our coaches.
After asking our coaches at CrossFit Southbay about these questions related to the kipping pull-up debate, I was reminded that you are all in good hands. The real answer to this debate is that you as the athlete have to take matters into your own hands. Our coaches have the knowledge, have educated all of you (if you haven’t been educated please ask), and are there to continue watching your form, giving cues and corrections as they see necessary.
The take-home message (so that it’s in the back of your mind as you read this discussion): coaches can teach you and give you recommendations for what they see safe and applicable to your movement as an athlete. They do their absolute best to keep you safe and stop you when they see something wrong, but after that it’s your responsibility to take what they say and apply it to your workouts.

The reason I wanted to bring up this topic is because there seems to be a pretty large debate on whether an athlete needs to be able to do a strict pull-up before doing kipping pull-ups. My PT mind automatically goes to “Well, yes of course they need a base strength so they don’t swing on their ligaments and stretch them out, among other issues.” I’ll save my full opinion till the end, but I wanted to share what your lovely coaches think in order to help answer any questions/concerns and help educate those who have not really thought too much about their pull-ups.

I’ll start with the most “strict first rule” and work down to the “strict is not necessary.”

  • Everyone should be first tested for their ability to hold hollow rock and superman on the ground. Then test their ability to do this while hanging on the bar. While practicing this, they are also working on 10 strict pull-ups before they are allowed to kip. Eccentric pull-ups are used to increase strength in low volumes. (This is a Navy SEAL theory.)
  • Another thought is recommending 3-5 strict pull-ups but not requiring this in the athlete before they teach the kip. The coach will teach the kipping progression and also have the athlete work on their strict pull-ups either with a band or with eccentrics. If the kipping progression is not going well, the athlete may be told not to do kipping pull-ups until they get stronger (in the arms and core) but they are not forbidden from doing kipping (which means it’s up to the athlete to ultimately decide). “Encourage athletes to build pre-requisite strength through strict pull-ups instead of relying on the kip before they are ready or capable.”
  • The last major thought was that some athletes may be able to build enough strength through kipping first and working on strict later. The idea behind this is that muscle adaptation occurs through the kip, and some athletes have seen improvements with their strict abilities while just working on the kip. “It may be the case for some that full range of motion kipping pull ups done at high reps CAN cause the lats and biceps to adapt more aggressively than strict alone.”

Coaches’ Thoughts on Those Who May Not Be Ready

Coaches' Thoughts on Those Who May Not Be Ready

Most coaches will stress the importance of getting the strength for the strict but also want you all to be able to learn the technique of the kipping pull-up so you can practice and improve.
“The best thing you can possibly do as a coach is educate the athlete of the possibility of injury if their shoulders are not ready for a kip yet.” Then the athlete takes whatever part of that they wish and modifies his/her workouts as they see necessary. Again, safety is also about the athletes taking responsibility. Also keep in mind that strict, controlled movements are always the first step AND the end goal.”

The overall theme from the coaches is that it’s case-by-case. “I don’t have a hard and fast rule. I take it case by case and teach the kipping swing before the pull-up.” No athlete is the same and has the same fitness background, therefore what works with one athlete may or may not work for another athlete. Most coaches will stress the importance of getting the strength for the strict but also want you all to be able to learn the technique of the kipping pull-up so you can practice and improve. “Proper technique with any movement (e.g.- snatch) can largely compensate for what an athlete lacks in strength.”

Page 1 2 Next »
Printable Version

We Are Scouting Top Writers

Are you passionate about fitness and have something to say? Reach a huge online community and get the discussion going - start writing for Tabata Times today!

Share this post
@TabataTimes on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook 

Contribute to this story by commenting below:

Advertise Here

Most Popular of All Time

szurley published the post You're doing it wrong. This is how you Bar Mup... on Tabata Times
Alright so in all honestly I still don't have a ring Mup a.k.a muscle up but let me tell you, bar...
zmosbarger published the post The Tug-o-War Between Playing to Your Strengths and Staying Constantly Varied on
We have been on the road for eighteen days now, a time span that has allowed us to visit fourteen...
CrossFit Chronic shared an image on Facebook

szurley published the post Skipping Leg Day on
OK so you are probably rolling your eyes thinking about the last time someone at a CrossFit gym...
CrossFit Tyson's Corner shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit Fairfax shared a link on Facebook

Two weeks before our Nutrition Challenge officially starts!

CrossFit Reston shared a link on Facebook

Two weeks before our Nutrition Challenge officially starts!

CrossFit Falls Church shared an image on Facebook

Last call before Fall Whole 30 kicks off September 17th! Join Amy and Bonny at CFA September 11th, 7:00 pm if you have any questions about this CFA/CFFC challenge! Folks who want to drop off their $25 buy-in are free to come by and do that as well! Note: If you have already attended info sessions for Whole 30 before then this meeting is completely optional. Just email Amy and Bonny that you would like to join! harris.amy22@gmail.com and bonnyc@gmail.com

CrossFit Chronic shared a link on Facebook

http://crossfitchronic.com/2014/09/10/091114-thurs/

CrossFit Chronic posted an article
Brickhouse CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

"A foundation of quality food needs to be in place. However, once that’s in, basing your diet on daily macros allows flexibility in what you can add to this base." Oh-oh. What is Jay up to now?

CrossFit RVA shared an image on Facebook

A strong midline is imperative to hold plank positions. How does Duncan look? _____________________________ #burpee #crossfit #crossfitrva

CrossFit Reston posted on Facebook

Happy birthday to Sarah Pomeroy!! Birthday burpees > spinning!!!

CrossFit Tyson's Corner shared an image on Facebook

Keep it simple. #crossfit #rkc #intensity #CFTC

CrossFit Chesapeake shared an image on Facebook

We are a week into our "Everything in Moderation" Nutrition Challenge. The high-fat, low-carb approach is taking some people out of their comfort zones. Not so for Tara, she's posting some gourmet-lookin' pictures on our challenge group page. Whether you're doing the challenge or not, have you tried any new recipes this week? Share them with us! That's what the community is for :) (Thanks to Tara for the photo!)

Brickhouse CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

tarynhaggerstone published the post CrossFit: What Makes a Good Competition? on
Over the past couple years, the number of people who do CrossFit has gone through the roof, and...
Fentress CrossFit posted on Facebook

Wednesday's WOD: 21-15-9 Over the bar Burpees Power Cleans 135/95# Then 50 Sit-Ups 50 Ball Slams

CrossFit 757 shared a link on Facebook

L-Sit & 3 Rds: Run + Power Snatch: Accumulate 3 mins in L sit/hang/hold Then 3 rounds: 800m run 10 power snatch (165/110)

CrossFit 757 posted an article
paleobutter published the post Paleo Paella on Nutrition WOD
This is a Paleo version of the Valencia style of paella. Adaptions include smoked/ grilled chicken...
Patriot CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

Once you learn how to Pose, fall, and pull you must learn one other crucial piece of running technique: cadence. […]

CrossFit West Springfield posted an article
CrossFit Shadyside shared a link on Facebook

http://crossfitshadyside.blogspot.com/2014/09/wednesday-91014.html

CrossFit Advance posted on Facebook

For those of you with smartphones there is a free app you can download to automatically calculate your weights for this new strength cycle. Search "Wendler Calculator" or "5/3/1 Calculator" all you have to do is enter you 1 Rep Max and make sure the "use 90%" is activated, and it will tell you what whats to use.

Compound CrossFit posted an article
Ballston CrossFit shared an image on Facebook

J. Humenay published the post Answering The Question - "Why Do You Lift?" on
Recently, I've been asked the question, "Why do you do Olympic lifts? There are so many other ways...
CrossFit Chesapeake posted an article
CrossFit Rosslyn posted an article
CrossFit Falls Church shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit Rosslyn shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit Rosslyn shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit Rosslyn shared an image on Facebook

Patriot CrossFit shared a link on Facebook

When Serious Becomes TOO Serious Many of us take our fitness, and our training, pretty seriously. Serious is good — it allows you to dedicate yourself to getting better at...

CrossFit Pittsburgh posted an article
CrossFit Arlington shared a link on Facebook

Wed 10 Aug 2014 http://wp.me/p2SUDs-1cT

CrossFit Arlington posted an article
Trident CrossFit posted an article
Patriot CrossFit posted an article
CrossFit Integrated Fitness shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Reston shared a link on Facebook

Skill - Strict HSPU 4 rounds for time: • 10 Strict HSPU • 15 Power Snatch 95#/65# Core - 2 x 15 Good Mornings 45/33#

CrossFit Old Town shared a link on Facebook

CrossFit Rubicon posted an article
CrossFit Chronic shared a link on Facebook

http://crossfitchronic.com/2014/09/09/091014-wed/

CrossFit Pittsburgh posted on Facebook

Available right now: 1 pair of Men's Cordura WOD Shorts Size 33" Retail $60.00 yours for $40.00.

astewart30 published the post Size Doesn't Matter on
From the time I was 10 years old I have been aware of my size. I have always known how much I weigh...
CrossFit KSX posted on Facebook

Tuesday's Workout Strength: 10 min EMOM 3 Deadlift @ 70% of 3RM Conditioning: 12min EMOM 3 Power cleans 155/115 5 strict pull-ups Rest 2 min: 3 rounds of: 1 min elbow plank 45 sec max supermans 30 sec Russian twist with weight 20/15 * 30 sec rest between rounds*

CrossFit Iron City posted on Facebook

This week's challenge is: 3 min AMRAP of 20 DU's Jason L. already has 2 wins down, who is going to take the top spot this week?

CrossFit Arlington shared an image on Facebook

CrossFit Center City shared a link on Facebook

#DIDYOUKNOW that CFCC offers Custom Fit Meals? These fresh, healthy meals are a great option for weeks when you're especially busy. They offer a huge menu that rotates week to week, and there's no commitment required. Use code CENTERCITY to take 10% off your first order. If you're thinking about participating in the #cfccrecharge or are struggling to find healthy options on-the-go, give CFM a try! #nutrition #paleo #paleoish http://crossfitcc.com/a-new-option-for-healthy-convenient-eats-at-cfcc/

CrossFit Center City shared an image on Facebook

Don't forget we are holding a 2 hour introductory Strongman clinic on Sunday September 28th. Link to sign up is in the comments. Email Record at record@crossfitcc.com if you have any questions about it and remember it is open to both CFCC member and non-members!

CrossFit Prime posted an article
CrossFit Prime posted an article
CrossFit Athletics posted on Facebook

SFH Fish Oil and *new* pure protein (without Creatine) is in stock!! Get it while it's hot.

Kristy Parrish published the post How Julie Foucher Became Julie Foucher on
Editor's Note: "How Julie Foucher Became Julie Foucher" was originally posted to the Beyond the...
WhatWouldJohnMackEat published the post Portuguese Style Littleneck Clams on
Littleneck clams are hands down my favorite seafood. I eat them raw, steamed or cooked Portuguese...
CrossFit Prime posted an article
CrossFit Focus shared an image on Facebook

Jeremiah swinging the kettlebell with authority.

CrossFit Focus shared a link on Facebook

You don't get what you want - you get what you work for.

@TabataTimes on Twitter

Watch the latest episode of GPTV