Why Women CAN Do Pull-ups: The Rebuttal

Page:  1 Next »
Print

“Women: you can do pull-ups. Do not believe the hype.” – Hamilton Nolan
On October 25th, 2012, the New York Times published their (now) infamous article – “Why Women Can’t Do Pull-ups” – that caused an indignant uproar of sorts in the fitness community at large. The following day, CrossFit.com published a strong rebuttal to this piece and posted a montage photo of women doing pull-ups as well as links to videos of Miranda Oldroyd doing strict pull-ups, Nadia Shattila performing 100 pull-ups for time, and a group of women making fun of the stereotype that women can’t do pull-ups.

But a host of other voices piped up in support of strong women everywhere, thank goodness, to explain why women not being able to do pull-ups is just a myth. Read two of our favorite responses below.

“Yes, Women Can Do Pull-Ups”

Rather than exclude an entire gender from being able to achieve a pull-up, Hamilton Nolan of Gawker.com encourages women… and offers a mild-but-valid critique of the study run by the University of Dayton referenced in the New York Times article.

You should know better than to take fitness advice from the New York Times. The latest reason: their story today entitled, “Why Women Can’t Do Pull-Ups.” Women: you can do pull-ups. Do not believe the hype.

Is it usually harder for a woman to do a pullup than it is for a man, due to biological differences in muscle mass and upper body strength and body fat percentages?

Yes. It is generally harder for women to do pullups. Does that mean that women cannot do pullups? No. It does not

Any healthy woman, absent any serious physical injuries or deformities, can be trained to do a pullup.

Today’s Tara Parker-Pope story, with its hyperbolic headline (as hyperbolic headline aficionados, we can forgive that), details a study that purports to prove (??) that not all women can do pullups. The methodology:

[Exercise] researchers from the University of Dayton found 17 normal-weight women who could not do a single overhand pull-up. Three days a week for three months, the women focused on exercises that would strengthen the biceps and the latissimus dorsi – the large back muscle that is activated during the exercise. They lifted weights and used an incline to practice a modified pull-up, raising themselves up to a bar, over and over, in hopes of strengthening the muscles they would use to perform the real thing. They also focused on aerobic training to lower body fat.

The results: the women’s upper body strength increased by a third, their body fat dropped 2%… and only four out of the 17 women could do a pullup at the end of the study.

If you have trained three months and you still can’t do a pullup, what should you do? Train longer. Train harder. Train more. Train smarter. Train with greater specificity. Eventually, you will be able to do a pullup.
Does this prove that women cannot do pullups? No. This proves that 13 of the women in this study need to continue training to do a pullup. It also proves, I might add, that these exercise researchers have failed to design an optimal training program to train women to do pullups. Though the description above is vague, anyone who knows this shit can tell you that simply strengthening your back and biceps is no guarantee that you will be able to do more (or a) pullup. If you want to train with the specific goal of doing a pullup, it’s best to do pullups—assisted pullups with bands or a machine, hanging from the bar trying to do pullups, negative pullups in which you lower yourself from the bar—things that most closely resemble actually doing pullups. (Yes, losing body fat and acquiring overall strength also help.) If you do this, for long enough, with sufficient intensity and dedication, you will eventually do a pullup.

I congratulate the University of Dayton researchers for proving that three sub-optimal workouts a week for three months is an insufficient level of training for most women to be able to do a pullup.

Crossfit has trained literally thousands of regular women across the country to do entire pullup workouts.
If you have trained three months and you still can’t do a pullup, what should you do? Train longer. Train harder. Train more. Train smarter. Train with greater specificity. Eventually, you will be able to do a pullup. Crystal West, who is 44 years old, can do 39 pullups. You can do a pullup. Crossfit has trained literally thousands of regular women across the country to do entire pullup workouts. You can do a pullup.

Do not let anyone tell you that you can’t.

Gawker.com originally posted this article on October 25, 2012. 

Page 1 2 Next »
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Printable Version

We Are Scouting Top Writers

Are you passionate about fitness and have something to say? Reach a huge online community and get the discussion going - start writing for Tabata Times today!

Share this post
@TabataTimes on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook 

Contribute to this story by commenting below:

Advertise Here

Most Popular of All Time

@TabataTimes on Twitter

Watch the latest episode of GPTV